Horrors of war meet 21st century digital media
By Larry Shaughnessy
A platoon of Marines engages the enemy in a deadly firefight that lasts days. When it's over, many Americans are dead, as are many enemy troops. Some surviving Marines cut the ears off the enemy and attach them to their helmets.
Had this been in Afghanistan, someone might have taken out a cell phone, snapped a picture of the helmets and maybe even posted it on the Internet. A major controversy would ensue, rising all the way to the very top of the U.S. military.
But this wasn't Afghanistan, it was Vietnam. And other than those young Marines, the only person who found out was their platoon commander, Lt. Karl Marlantes. "I went 'you can't do this.' "
Marlantes instructed his Marines to remove the ears from their helmets and bury the enemy soldiers whose bodies they desecrated. "They started to cry, because what it did it brought them back to their humanity." Marlantes said.
Marlantes, who was awarded the Navy Cross for heroism in Vietnam, said what he saw in there happens in all wars. "I had the sense that is was like a high school kid who wants to show the letter on his letter jacket, proof he'd killed the soldiers who killed his buddies," Marlantes said.
"The difference was they didn't have the ability to take pictures of it and send them home before I got there," Marlantes said in a phone interview with CNN.
The unfiltered nature of new media in the 21st century war has created a string of controversies for the U.S. military all the way up to Secretary of Defense Leon Panetta.
The latest is the publication by The Los Angeles Times of several pictures showing U.S. soldiers posing with bodies of suspected Afghan insurgents. Panetta condemned the photos but explained, "This is war. And I know that war is ugly, and it's violent."
It's eerily similar to what Panetta said when he visited Afghanistan immediately after the murders of 17 Afghan civilians allegedly by an American soldier. "This is a war."
Marlantes says photos like what the Times published and the video of Marines urinating on dead Taliban fighters that was made public recently are just another form of "trophy taking" that has been part of war for thousands of years.
Fighters in the American West took scalps. "In World War II, guys gloated over dead Germans and Japanese," he said. Even "primitive tribes took heads and shrunk them."
Such photos and trophy-taking have long been a violation of American military regulations. So why does it continue to happen? Marlantes believes it's the nature of war and the warriors.
"The ideal marine or paratrooper or army infantry guy is 19 or 20 years old. They are not the kind of person who is going to second guess - 'Gee, lieutenant, should we think about doing it another way?' " Marlantes said.
"We are taught thou shalt not kill, so how do you get a 19- or 20-year-old to actually pull the trigger? Well, he has to think of the enemy as not human, that's the psychological trick to do. The problem is how do you get back out of that mode fast enough so that you begin to behave like a human being again? Oh, that body there is a human being, it's not some animal, and I'm gonna take the antlers off and stick it on my barn door. You have to switch back, and it's very difficult to do especially if you are 19."
Why is it harder for a 19-year-old private than say a 30-year-old segreant? Part of it is physiology.
Scientists believe that the part of the brain called the frontal cortex isn't fully developed in young adults. And that part of the brain is partly responsible for decision making and moderating social behavior. That's why young people often make good soldiers who will follow dangerous orders to risk their lives in combat without questioning their leaders, but on the flip side, they don't see the wrong in cutting off the ears of the enemy or urinating on corpses.
The Pentagon is fighting a difficult battle to prevent future such atrocities being made public, but Manlantes said that doesn't mean the military leaders don't have a role in stopping such activities.
"On the sense that 'this is war.' Panetta is correct. If you are going to go to war, really horrible ugly things are unleashed, but I would go the extra step, which is at some point there has to be a responsibility for those people in charge."
@natlsecuritycnn on Twitter
Nothing!
https://www.wholess.com/product/category/1869
Hmm is anyone else having problems with the images on this blog loading? I'm trying to find out if its a problem on my end or if it's the blog. Any feed-back would be greatly appreciated.
https://www.hairstylescool.com
I am grateful for your post. I'd like to write my opinion that the expense of car insurance differs from one coverage to another, since there are so many different issues which give rise to the overall cost. As an example, the model and make of the car or truck will have a huge bearing on the fee. A reliable ancient family vehicle will have a more affordable premium compared to a flashy racecar.
https://www.ifashionstyles.com
Dams in most cases it is!
https://miginia.com
Magnificent beat ! I would like to apprentice while you amend your site, how can i subscribe for a blog site? The account aided me a applicable deal. I had been a little bit acquainted of this your broadcast provided bright clear concept.
http://yourmatrixcashmachine.com
Good ?V I should certainly pronounce, impressed with your website. I had no trouble navigating through all the tabs as well as related information ended up being truly simple to do to access. I recently found what I hoped for before you know it at all. Quite unusual. Is likely to appreciate it for those who add forums or anything, site theme . a tones way for your client to communicate. Excellent task..
http://www.vreyrolinomit.com/
Really Appreciate this blog post, can I set it up so I receive an email sent to me whenever you write a new article?
https://www.cravefreebies.com
My husband has arthritis and this tool is the best we've found to help open bottles and jars.
https://bestproductlab.com/tag/automatic-jar-opener/
As we got closer to the moving date my wife and I had more questions as we were packing our own boxes and put in a call lớn Tom’. We left messages on his direct line but were never called back. Instead, we were contacted by Cindy’ who was going lớn be the new contact to answer questions. We insisted lớn talk to Tom’ since he never called back and she said “he was on another line but would call us back in about an hour.” Needless lớn say, it’s 3 weeks later and we’re still waiting…
https://360auto.vn/huong-dan-su-dung-auto-mu-vuot-thoi-dai/
My husband and i ended up being so relieved when Louis could finish off his investigation using the precious recommendations he gained while using the web pages. It’s not at all simplistic just to continually be releasing guidance that many the others could have been trying to sell. We really take into account we’ve got the website owner to appreciate for this. Most of the explanations you have made, the easy web site navigation, the relationships you can assist to create – it is all excellent, and it’s really letting our son and the family imagine that the situation is entertaining, and that’s exceedingly indispensable. Thanks for all the pieces!
http://6dollarmillion.xyz
Somebody essentially help to make seriously posts I would state. This is the very first time I frequented your web page and thus far? I amazed with the research you made to create this particular publish incredible. Excellent job!
https://extraproxies.com/buy-proxies/2000-proxy-pack
Howdy just wanted to give you a quick heads up. The text in your content seem to be running off the screen in Opera. I'm not sure if this is a formatting issue or something to do with web browser compatibility but I thought I'd post to let you know. The design look great though! Hope you get the issue resolved soon. Kudos
https://extraproxies.com/buy-proxies/200-proxy-pack
I want to to thank you for this excellent read!! I certainly loved every little bit of it. I have got you book marked to look at new things you post…
https://extraproxies.com/tag/beijing/
Thank you for any other fantastic article. The place else may just anybody get that type of information in such an ideal approach of writing? I have a presentation subsequent week, and I'm on the search for such information.
My dear ibn Franko, I would like to meet you at your time and choice of places so we can have a little talk
Hello er 2wie gohts? adr foeteli aa sehr guet sind er scho bald in aatirulse?mer sind etz in kalabarri noerdlich vo perth. goend er au no in norde oder noed? sus choenntmer sich jo mol irgendswo troeffe..sind etz no 2 wuche mitm auto underwaegs bis uf broome und nohor no 2 taeg in perth.am 18. maerz flueged mir wieder id schwiiz.bis evtl. bald!gruesslidenise und angela
I'm extremely inspired with your writing skills as well as with the layout on your blog. Is that this a paid subject matter or did you customize it yourself? Either way keep up the excellent quality writing, it's uncommon to peer a great weblog like this one nowadays..
Not since the slaughtering of the American Aboriginals have so many non comba tants been shot so needlessly and the Genocidal Tactics used upon Iraqui peoples can never be justifide. The US used Iraq as no less than a Live Fire Exercize and a Weapons and tactics proveing grounds and the Iraq peoples as live targets ever since Gulf I. The HONOR is in the CAUSE not in the amount of carnage one is capable of rendering.
Keep quiet a lot has happend sense the 19th century you idiot. How about the two world wars that happend. You think your special don't make me laugh. My grand Dad is special 94 years old going to be 95. He has seen it all and done it all. There where still Czars in Russia and Pancho Villa still raiding the border of America. He fought against the Nazis and killed a few. He's seen all the wars of the twentieth century and those going on in the 21st. He knows that it never ends. An you are just one of the millions who have said the same thing in countless languages over countless centuries. War is a trait that is in our DNA just as our eye colour.
Keep on sucking that khaki cock.
Maybe you and masturbator Jo can have a snowball contest to see who's the bigger patriot.
Aboriginals ?
Australians, moron.
Aboriginals is an Anthropolgical term for peoples of Ancient cultures with a cultural root, While today we still have many Abortiginal Tribes one could aolmost say that those of N. America are no longer and for that matter neither are the ones of Austrailia: with only a very tiny differing groups still very much as they always were and those are n mainly the Amazonian Rain Basin.
I am old and talk to, but I do not answer myself, but to Rob, who says he has a hereditory genetic defect in his DNA patterns, I think I am human and I do not think but I know I have talked to more vets, including some from the Native American of the civilized cultures,, Mexican War, that would of been my Great Uncle or my Grandpas brother, on up till today.
Gramps was in WWI France when he sent his 1/2 Nations Tribal Mom a Birthday card, her Birthday was just one month before; mail from the Front was slow but no morfe faster in Paris so it took until exactly to the day of his birthday before she recieved it, He was 15 years old and in the hospital suffering from partial loss of one lung from mustard gas.
I remember the Stars on thier windows and the pictures on the wall from WWII; PATRIOTIC to the corp and if you did not stand when the Flag went by, take off your hat and place palm on heart it hurt like hell, as he was as strong as a bull until he died.
Gramps, taught me how to count, add, subtract, and even divide by using an old deck of cards from France that today would get him arrested for showing porno to a kid, and history was taught by old pictures and letters of our ancestors dating back to the mid 1620's when an Irish Bastard of an Irish lass and a Brit soldier got tired of English oppression.
When I asked him why so many of our ancestors fought in wars he told me to go read Tennysons, answer, Because their fathres did, and he was speaking of those damn far north Scotch Welch and wild Irish mud and rock hovled filth called Crackers, a bunch of dumb inbreds the lot of them.
He could say that because our Irish ancestors were of High Borne, even if they were Bastards, they went to New England and became even more civilized whereas; the crackers went to the south of US and are still inbreeding there, so maybe inmdeed there may well be a wee bit of insanity in some of those folks lineages,
I know of war Vietnam, and have talked to many and my gramps and I took home many a drunken ex soldier from all three conflicts, WWI, WWII, and Korean who cried late at night when the men began to talk of wars fought long ago but still fresh as hell in their minds that night. What men said to men of war stayed with the men and not a one of them I can remember bragged about the war and spoke matter of factly about their experiences.
The big difference between then and now, those men and our nation( in the populaces eyes and minds at least) did not go looking and trying to enrage others so they could kill them and there is one hell of a lot of difference between Killers and soldiers, well at least there once was.
That goes all the way from privates to those who wear the brass on their hats and sit on warmed toilet seats in the Execuitive Branch and the Pentagon. who forment chaos and then destroy the local cultures to be supplanted by Corporate Interest.
It is more economical to our finacial interest to get them to kill each other, destroy their infrastructures and then we go in finish off the few left to bring stablity and order to the region, rebuild that infrastructure to our finacial desires, and then charge them unto death to rebuild their countrfy while we rob the country blind.
I have met and known quite well 2 Medal of Honor winners, one other but barely except to say Hi to and multiple Silver Star and minor pievecs of Bronze and crap metal medals and of the majority from the Korean and some rom The Nam none wanted to sit a brag about the killing all just went there did what needed to be done, hoping never again, and to get on with their lives, War was an Aberation not a norm to be striven for.
Nyan anan ah, Nyan a nn ah, My Gramps could of kicked your Gramps with only one lung and one hand tied behind his back, but then Gramps did not have any genetic defects other than beiong Yankee Smart and a hard as nails SOB if you crossed him .
The best Warriors in the world, I do agree, but do please cut out that there is any Honor to anyting more than a Warrior Code . Fancy coins and sh?1 house smoke grenades will only get you free drinks.
This is not new- David cut off the head off the head of goliath and paraded it around- Achiles and paris, and shall we talk about what happened to the corpses of custer and his 7th cavalry?
Sarah Palin is the only one who can heal and re-unify our country. But in order to do so, she must return to her motorhome and resume her cross country tour. She will have to visit cities both large and small, speaking only to "real Americans", dispensing her sage advice and folksy, homespun common sense solutions. We can be a great nation again but we must all follow the "Palin Path". In the days , weeks, and months to come, I will elaborate on the "Palin Path" so that everyone has a clear understanding of Sarah Palin's vision for our country.
ibn Franko, I have seen the enemy we fight, and you would cower before them as they killed you. Every American soldier is a better human than you. At least they have the guts to stand up and fight versus some coward typing at his computer. I am here on ground, and although the US forces are not perfect, we are bleeding and dieing in an effort to do the right thing. If you don't like the war, bring it up with the politicians, but don't you dare condemn the men who carry out the orders. Especially from some cushy computer chair in your mom's basement. I watch American soldiers go out every day and try to help the Afghans.
Fuck you! You haven't seen shit. If anyone's in their mommy's basement, it's you. Bullshit patriots make me laugh. You wanna die for nothing? For politicians and bankers and chickenhawks? Be my fucking guest.
haha, its funny because I'm literally typing this sitting in Afghanistan after being on mission all day. Good luck to you bro. I understand people's disagreement with the war, but to take it out on the soldiers just shows how out of touch you are. We are humans just like you, and we protect your right to run your mouth, so enjoy it. And the next time you meet an infantryman like myself after coming home from the war, I encourage you to run your mouth some more. You seem like a big tough guy, I'm sure it will work out great for you. And tell your mom whats up for me.
On the ground? More like on your knees.
You couldn't find Afghanistan on a map.
Well you just proved something to me. You have proven that you are one of those guy's that sit's on Yahoo chat all day talking sh$t. And cutting others down. I have seen it when I am home on leave. My son goes on that chat and shows me these loser's that think that they are some kind of chat god. Listen up sonny! In my 33 years first with the 101st Airborne Division and Currently with the 5th Special Forces (Green Beret) Currenly Deployed over here. I don't see you signing up for anything, except maybe food stamps. When you man up and go to war you might have something to say. But when you disrespect one of our brothers over here< over a computer I might add. You have crossed a line that shouldn't be crossed. I would put any 17-18 year old soldier against you anyday and why don't you diss a soldier to his face? because your a computer pushing wimp that has a big mouth when we don't know who you are. Oh Mommys callin you she wants to know why you have been down in the basement for days. LITTLE PUNK with a big mouth.
Master Sergeant Jo 5th Special Forces Over here.
Hey really don't mind me I'm a shiteating liberal cocksucker. After I get pounded in the ass in the morning I like to troll forums – gotta get my kicks somehow other than pulling tricks.
Jo – since you like to go on about those who are on food stamps, what would you call someone, like yourself, who depends on the government for a paycheck? Oh, that's right, a hypocrite. Master Sgt.? More like masturbator. You war lovers crack me up. Fucking dickless chickenhawks. Mouth-breathing, knuckle-dragging war-monger scum.
As for the 'other' ibn Franko; couldn't come up with your own name? Too difficult, no? Was "I Love Cock" already taken?
Back to you, Jo; STOP WITH ALL THE BULLSHIT ABOUT HOW 'YOU'RE FIGHTING FOR US'. Because you're not. You couldn't find Afghanistan on a map, let alone pass a basic aptitude test to qualify as canon fodder.
That just proved to everyone what the gutless wonder of a dumbass you are. Thats ok spew your baseless crap. you love the fact that you can spew your insults to someone who can't find you. It is a fact that you got beat up as a kid. so now you hide behind your computer talking shit to a person that could kill you with a touch of my finger. fool. one day someone will find where you live and then you'll be sorry you opened your big mouth
Spoken like a true bully. Whats the matter, sweetheart – did I call you on your bullshit? Thirty-three years of suckling at the public teat makes you one hell of a welfare recipient, doesn't it. By the way (humor me on this one), what time is it right now – 'over there'?
It's 5:26 Pm. Suppertime you little piece of shit.
ibn Franko, what is your deal dude? you are the worst person.........literally you suck so bad that you are the worst person. There are over 7 billion people on this planet. And somehow you managed to be the worst. As we speak, there are 1,000 little microscopic sperms rolling off your moms chin that are worth more then you.
Gotta agree with you on that. He is just some little antagonist that get's his jollies from doing just that. Everyone on here can see through his crap. He should just pack his shit and get out of the states before someone shuts him up for good
Hey, Jo – maybe once your heroic tenure as a glorified welfare recipient comes to an end, you can get a job with the Nazis at the TSA, where you can continue to bully and brutalize the elderly, the disabled and the very young. All in the name of 'freedom', of course. And bonus!.........it being a tax-funded government agency, you can still sponge off of the rest of us who actually work for a living. If it weren't for the military, you would have been on food stamps a looooooonnnngg time ago......you little piece of shit.
Oops!.......I'm sorry. You're not a piece of shit – you're just a socialist. Like Obama. Hahahahahahahahahaha!!!!!!!!
It's perfectly clear that all you are is some little kid being an antagonist. I get paid to fight for our country, something of which you obviously are not a part of. If you hate the US so much all I can say is pack up your shit and get out before you mouth off to one of us military people in person and they decide that you don't matter, which you don't. your just one of those kids that hides behind your computer because both of us know you are too afraid to say something to someones face. Never have I seen a loser like you on such magnitude. and if you look at the posts all of us here know what you are. And your job at McDonald's is not relevant. Quit your job and get out of the United States before something happens to you for opening your mouth to the wrong person
You get paid to fight. Sure. More like you get paid to shuffle papers at a desk, you fucking pogue. And I just love the banal analogies of dim-wits and jar-heads such as yourself; i.e., "if you don't like it here, then leave". Brilliant! How original. Did you come up with that one all by yourself, genius? I guess freedom of speech only applies to those self-chosen few who feel that they are the sole purveyors of what is right or what is truth. Sure, I don't agree with you, but I would never suggest that you, or anyone else I disagree with, can't say what they want, no matter how repugnant I may find it. And this is why you're nothing more than a basic garden-variety hypocrite. Furthermore, I haven't implied nor suggested, that you should have your ass kicked, simply because we are in disagreement. Too bad you can't say the same.
That said, finish your tour and get your ass home in one piece. (yeah, I'm giving you the benefit of the doubt) And for what it's worth, the 'other' ibn Franko – the one who refers to himself as a Liberal pussy – ain't me.
The point of this article isn't descecration of the enemy, or discrediting the military; it's to demonstrate that technology today has the capability of affecting political decisions about engagement in combat.
Thoughtful comments, ibn Franko.
As wrong as it is to desicrate human bodies, we have to remimber that we arn't the ones fighting Americas wars and they are. We have to understand what they are going through.
I couldn't give a shit what they're going through. They volunteered. Fuck 'em!
ibn Franko,
Really? You sound just like the troops who commited these acts in the first place. Your choice use of the word Fuck makes you sound just as ignorant.
Having served in both Iraq and Afgan, I can tell you that a MAJORITY of our troops are law abiding Americans fighting a war they did not ask for. Fighting for another countries right to freedom. Yes they volunteered and should be praised for doing a job which is not publically held in high regard. So your condemnation of the MAJORITY for the actions of the MINORITY is ignorant and uncalled for. Dont support the war effort or the troops, but at least research the facts to back up your statements, becuase frankly you sound like a rambling idiot.
You're right of course. I am a pussy coward liberal, the closest to fighting I've ever done is multiplayer on Modern Warfare. Much easier to anonymously attack someone over the internet to make up for all of my inadequacies as a human being.
Thats because your probably about 16 years old and still sucking your moms tit you gutless hide behind your computer agitator. You wouldn't have the balls to spend one day over here
We can't fight a ruthless and unforgiving enemy with smiles and handshakes. Niceness goes out the window when bullets start flying over your head. Take a vacation to Afghanistan and try to talk peace and see how that works out for ya.
Fuck off, John Wayne.
ibn Franko,
Have you served? You know better yet have you ever watched the life flow out of your best friend? Watched helplessly as the vehicle your firends are in explodes into a fireball of death and destruction?
These men and women are placed into situations which most will never endure. I am by no means advocating the actions of the minority. I am stressing the importance of understanding that everyone is different and handle combat stress differently. These individuals should be prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law, however, ignorant people like you should be educated. That way these needless ridiculous comments can be avioded.
No I haven't served I'm a stupid libtard douchebag. I'm just a chickenshit coward.
Good article. There is no desecration of bodies by taking a picture and showing happiness at the death of the enemy.
In war that is a job well done and what you are paid to do. What about the bodies which are left on the streets while the local dogs take a nibble out of the parts lying about? War is a gruesome nasty business!
CNN IS REACHING BACK FOUR DECADES TO DISCREDIT OUR TROOPS !
They don't have to dig that far.
you cowardly piece of shit! keep hiding behind that computer while we fight for america over here. your the lowest kind of species, A COWARD
Jo you are right. I hate myself so I'm just going to anonymously take a shit on a forum to make myself feel better about how much of a human turd I am.
http://freeuntodeath.wordpress.com/
http://freeuntodeath.wordpress.com/
Please check out this page,
Do not be silent, Do not be part of the problem anymore.
We can change things.