Pulling back the curtain of secrets: The 'Case File' on NSA's Fran Fleisch
March 25th, 2012
02:29 PM ET

Pulling back the curtain of secrets: The 'Case File' on NSA's Fran Fleisch

by Suzanne Kelly

Editor's note: In the Security Clearance "Case File" series, CNN national security producers profile the key members of the intelligence community. As part of the series, Security Clearance is focusing on the roles women play in the U.S. intelligence community.

She is the highest-ranking woman entrusted with the National Security Agency's most-guarded secrets. Inside Fran Fleisch's mind are the details of the country's most delicate and sophisticated intelligence-gathering operations, intertwined with the knowledge and experience needed to run the world's most secretive spy agency.

As executive director of the NSA, Fleisch is No. 3 in the management chain, reporting to Deputy Director John "Chris" Inglis. He recently assumed more responsibilities when Director Keith Alexander took on the extra job of heading U.S. Cyber Command, which is dedicated to the growing national security threat posed by those using keyboards and servers as their weapons of choice.

The NSA's intelligence prowess on matters of signals intelligence and information assurance is widely considered to be unrivaled. If there is a cell phone conversation originating from some faraway part of the world where terrorist operations are being planned, chances are good that the NSA is listening in. It has earned a reputation as perhaps the most feared intelligence agency in the U.S., probably because it has also tended to be the most secretive.

Fleisch is on a mission to change that. It's important to her to show the world that the NSA is actually transparent on issues where it doesn't compromise the valued sources or methods that the intelligence community holds close.

"We conduct our mission in silence, you know. We really grew up that way. There wasn't necessarily an expectation that we would or should or that it would be appropriate for us to be out in the public. That has changed a lot in recent years, and of course, one of our main tenets is transparency," Fleisch said.

With 32 years under her belt, she now presides over an agency divided by design. Part of the NSA's mission known as the Information Assurance section focuses on keeping the enemy from gaining access to sensitive information, and the Signals Intelligence division looks to collect and use intelligence to support military and counterterrorism operations.

Although the NSA's warriors wear a uniform that is more likely to include a pocket protector, the mathematicians, engineers and scientists who fill its ranks are scoping out the battlefield for both real-world and cyberwar operations carried out against those seeking to do harm to American.

Navigating her way

Fleisch found the NSA by accident. She was working on Wall Street and attending a summer language immersion program when an NSA recruiter paid a visit.

"They appeal to your patriotism. I think that is one of the things we still do today," said Fleisch, who also credits the recruiter with sparking her curiosity. "They are able to tell you just enough about the unique contributions that you'll be able to make that it was very enticing for me, so I went ahead and applied a little bit on a lark."

Fleisch was a business and finance major who also happened to have an affinity for language, studying Russian, French and Latin. She was an interesting addition to the agency's Russia unit, then dominated by men, most of whom were quite a bit older than she and had served in the military.

"I'm not sure who was more surprised, but I have to say that considering how different our backgrounds were, it was really a very welcoming environment from the outset."

Fleisch was a Russian linguist and an analyst/reporter, and more important, she was part of the team responsible for reporting Russian intelligence to those higher up the NSA chain of command.

The position she holds today is a natural extension of how the threat has changed. Attacks can be launched from behind a computer, and because the nature of the enemy has changed, it isn't always clear who the bad guys are or, more important, where they are conspiring.

"We've had a couple of transformational opportunities over the course of my career," Fleisch said. "The fall of the Soviet Union, I think, is one where we needed to adjust and reallocate resources, and many people who started as Russian linguists, maybe their skills were needed or could be applied in other places, so I think we have done a very good job of that."

A new NSA

With an enemy that is constantly changing and new enemies popping up around the world, Fleisch knows that the agency's most pressing challenge is making sure it is ready for what is coming next.

"The world we live in is changing so quickly, and there are so many things that we know about the threat and that we know about the technology and how that's being used by our adversaries, it really behooves us to make sure that we are positioning our enterprise," Fleisch said.

Positioning that enterprise means finding more efficient ways to comb through the volumes of information the agency collects, sticking within the legal limits of what it is allowed to collect and how it uses it. At the same time, the NSA must use transparency as a weapon against critics who believe that it has sinister motives.

What about those fears? They were played out on the big screen in Hollywood's "Enemy of the State," in which Will Smith's character, an American citizen, is targeted by a sinister agency that tracks his every move in real time.

The fact that the NSA is so powerful and secretive does make people nervous. The fact that it is in a prime position to find out just about anything about anyone has made it a favorite target of conspiracy theorists and Hollywood, who run scenarios of all of that power being run by a Big Brother-type goverment.

Fleisch insists that those scenarios couldn't be further from the truth and points to laws that govern what information the agency can collect on Americans.

But groups like the ACLU have legally challenged a controversial domestic surveillance program that the agency called a terrorist surveillance program. It was instituted under President Bush after September 11 and allowed the NSA to monitor phone conversations of people inside the United States. An appeals court ultimately refused to rule on the legality of the program, but the issue highlights the delicate territory that the NSA occupies between keeping Americans safe from attack and not compromising their civil liberties. Because of the nature of the debate, that is likely to remain an ongoing issue for an agency as secretive as the NSA.

"What I would want to convey to you, besides the brilliance and the strength of our agency being our people, is that one the values we embody here is adherence to the law and how prevalent that is and is really seminal to everything that we do," Fleisch said. "I think people feel an ownership of the secrets that have been trusted to them."

There is another way that the agency stands out, though. If you think that behind those barricades and checkpoints that protect its main building in Fort Meade, Maryland, sit a bunch of men in suits, you might be surprised by who is really making a significant number of the decisions there.

Fleisch says that 40% of the agency's leadership team is made up of women, a number more in line with the roles women play in the intelligence field overall. Some other agencies have a disproportionate number of women in the middle ranks compared with those in leadership positions. Fleisch credits the difference with the fact that there are just more women at the NSA who, like her, stuck around and have amassed the experience needed to take on those higher-ranking roles.

"Most people have kind of grown up in our system and have earned their positions as a result of their demonstrated ability and capability in our discipline, so besides me, our chief of staff is a woman, and the leads for our two major missions are women. Our (signals intelligence) directorate and our information assurance directorate are all women," Fleisch noted.

Maybe Hollywood will have to make a wardrobe change.

soundoff (26 Responses)
  1. NickD

    Americans should be glad we have such agencies and dedicated people to run them. but we must always be critical of them and wary of them. Not because they have been abusive, we cannot know that anyway, but because their abilities could be abused under the right (or wrong) circumstances. new technologies are emerging faster and faster and their capabilities can stagger the mind. (read it actually) We may have a solid group running these organizations now, but as time progresses and the animosity between Americans of different political persuasion becomes more and more intense, bad things can happen.
    I am glad we have these groups and I am glad these fine folks are there now, but just because they are law abiding and respectful of all Americans now does not mean the people who replace them will be.

    April 10, 2012 at 12:20 am | Reply
  2. Daisuke

    Of all the celebrity daehts that could presage a big zombie outbreak, Michael Jackson's would be one of the more likely, don'tcha think?Oh well, have fun getting eaten by zombies.

    April 6, 2012 at 11:54 pm | Reply
  3. Town Drunk

    I'd hit it.

    March 26, 2012 at 12:44 pm | Reply
  4. the wise

    Let's not shed any more blood for Israel, nor squander our treasure.

    Down with criminal Israel.


    March 26, 2012 at 12:32 pm | Reply
  5. Mikel

    IF anyone beleives that the NSA is a constitutiional agency that only focuses on terrorism you are fools. The NSA is by far one of the most dangerous threats to our freedoms our country has ever known.

    March 26, 2012 at 9:17 am | Reply
    • The Rosenbergs

      Ssssshhhhh!.......................you'll wake up the sheep.

      March 26, 2012 at 12:03 pm | Reply
    • Karl

      One need only worry about NSA should the big government believers in the liberal ranks gain absolute control. They believe that government can do anything it wishes to insure its survival. This is the same belief that drove and continues to drive the secret police in all the socialist paradises known as the Peoples' Republic, the Socialist Republic, and any other government based on the beliefs espoused by Karl Marx that the government is the final and only thing that counts. You will claimed that Hitler's German does not fall into this category, but you will be wrong as the political party was the National Socialist Party, again proving the socialism is the root of the problem, enforcing the envy of one group at the expense initially of another, but evenually at the expense of all in the name of the all powerful state.

      March 28, 2012 at 12:46 pm | Reply
      • NickD

        Karl, you don't have to worry about liberals taking away your liberties. Thats just the fear mongering you have fallen victim to. Your paranoia about those that do not agree with AM radio is only what those on the right want you to believe.

        Look to the living conditions in second and third world nations, that is the way it used to be here before the ideas of human rights for all classes of people became the rallying cry of Americans. It is not liberal to want a middle class and a solid healthy working class. it is not liberal to want to see the poor have a chance to succeed. It is American to want these things. it is American to want decent working conditions and a pension for retirement. it is American to want to be able to bargain with your peers for a decent wage. it is American to want clean water and an education for your children. It is American to help your neighbor or the family down the street

        Don't let those who would divide us make you hate or despise ypur neighbor for their political ideas.

        April 10, 2012 at 12:32 am |
  6. zac mutts

    The fact that the NSA is so powerful and secretive does make people nervous

    March 26, 2012 at 3:25 am | Reply
  7. DecievedNation

    Go to the top of your browser and type http://www.itanimulli.com...

    Illuminati spelled backwards.....


    March 26, 2012 at 3:22 am | Reply
    • dojo

      Seriously... what's up with that? Inside joke? Not very funny – more like scarey!

      March 26, 2012 at 7:10 am | Reply
    • games are just games

      Keep digging and when you find the page that says IDIOT , stop there because you found the answer that you have been looking for , or just skip all that and look into the mirror .

      March 26, 2012 at 10:43 am | Reply
      • DecievedNation

        When i look into a mirror i see an American that isn't blinded by the media...Can they afford mirrors where your from? An IDIOT believes everything they're told

        March 26, 2012 at 8:56 pm |
      • eme

        Ha, Idiot is right. The article does sigh this brings out the crazy conspiracy theorists who should be on meds *sigh*

        March 27, 2012 at 12:06 pm |
  8. Lazitoh

    You may play god in having all the intel in the whole world but still America is not safe.

    March 26, 2012 at 2:46 am | Reply
  9. fauxhawk70

    Thumbs up to the men and women in these positions that risk their lives day in and day out to protect this great nation and our freedoms!

    Thank you.

    March 25, 2012 at 11:03 pm | Reply
  10. larry5

    If Obama hears that this lady believes in transparency, honesty and accountability it could mean the end of her career for violating the basic principals of his Administration.

    March 25, 2012 at 7:59 pm | Reply
    • dojo

      Obama rocks, and you FAIL! LOL!

      March 26, 2012 at 7:09 am | Reply
  11. duckforcover

    Seems to me the top American spy agency should not be transparent.

    March 25, 2012 at 6:15 pm | Reply
  12. Kenneth

    The only way for evil to win is for good men and women to sleep and do nothing

    March 25, 2012 at 5:46 pm | Reply
    • Cheese Wonton

      You might be surprised to discover that the people at the NSA, CIA, DoD or other intelligence gathering agencies of our government are citizens just like you, with the same or very similar concerns, and who love their country and their rights as much as anyone else in the US. They are a cross section of us. Yes, I know some of them, not at NSA but at other such agencies. Quality people all of them. They are not sinister at all, unless you are a foreign enemy of the US.

      March 25, 2012 at 7:59 pm | Reply
      • Jason Kendle

        Very well said. I agree with that 100%

        March 27, 2012 at 4:36 pm |
      • Karl

        Thank You. That was my personal experience during nearly 29 years in the intelligence community.

        March 28, 2012 at 12:48 pm |
  13. mipolitic

    well with the reports here from cnn in the last month, women are playing a huge roll in top level security . this is something that was proven in the second world war in france and the uk to be an asset of great value and trust.

    the women were wives and moms at night and through the day they carried some of the highest intel secrets at work. the russians quickly followed by deploying hundreds of women as agents of the kgb , and it was not to long ago we watch a young russian girl be accused of spying in both the uk and the usa before being deported back to russia with her cohorts , i bet this lady named in the above report was part of the team that uncovered this spy ring of russia , GOD SPEED AND DISCERNMENT TO HER AND COMPANY ! thank you for your service .

    March 25, 2012 at 5:15 pm | Reply

    tumbs up, for her.

    March 25, 2012 at 3:26 pm | Reply

Leave a Reply to NickD


CNN welcomes a lively and courteous discussion as long as you follow the Rules of Conduct set forth in our Terms of Service. Comments are not pre-screened before they post. You agree that anything you post may be used, along with your name and profile picture, in accordance with our Privacy Policy and the license you have granted pursuant to our Terms of Service.