Iran's growing "military dictatorship"
Supreme Leader Ayatollah Khamenei listens to a speech by Iranian President Ahmadinejad.
November 7th, 2011
07:00 AM ET

Iran's growing "military dictatorship"

By CNN Foreign Affairs Correspondent Jill Dougherty and CNN National Security Producer Jamie Crawford

It's a phrase Secretary of State Hillary Clinton seems to slip into with almost every comment about Iran these days: "I think Iran, unfortunately, is morphing into a military dictatorship."

That's how she put it in an interview on October 26, with BBC Persia. The expression appears to have first popped up during Clinton's February 2010, trip to the Middle East, where she said at a town hall appearance in Doha, Qatar, that U.N. sanctions are aimed at "enterprises controlled by the Revolutionary Guard, which we believe is, in effect, supplanting the government of Iran."

"We see that the government of Iran, the supreme leader, the president, the parliament, is being supplanted, and that Iran is moving toward a military dictatorship."

By "military dictatorship" the Obama administration means the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps-Quds Force (IRGC-QF) which experts at the Council on Foreign Relations describe as a "socio-military-political-economic force with influence reaching deep into Iran's power structure" and having control of "strategic industries, commercial services, and black-market enterprises."

Striking at the heart of that "military dictatorship," the Obama administration has aimed most of its recent economic sanctions at senior officers of the Quds Force.

Most recently, the U.S. Treasury Department designated five Iranians, including four senior Quds Force officers allegedly connected to a plot to assassinate Saudi Arabia's ambassador to the United States.

Referring to Iran's growing "military dictatorship," Secretary Clinton often adds a bit of mystery, saying, for example, in an aside to BBC Persia: "It's been a little confusing because we're not quite sure who makes decisions any more inside of Iran, which, I think, is an unfortunate sign and kind of goes along with the ascendancy of greater military power."

Clinton's rhetoric is being noticed by Iran experts, including Karim Sadjadpour of the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace in Washington. "'When she says it's becoming a military dictatorship, she's right," Sadjadpour says.

"In the past they used to refer to Iran as a, quote unquote, clerical regime. That's no longer true."

Sadjadpour says the West often concentrates on the religious and clerical aspects of Iran's leadership, including Iran's supreme leader, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei.

The ayatollah is more powerful than Iran's President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, with authority to appoint the heads of influential posts in the military, government, and judiciary. But Sadjadpour says that is misleading. "The Supreme Leader is ... wearing this turban and clerical garb. A more apt sort of clothing for him would be military fatigues."

Ayatollah Khamenei, he says, is "seeking legitimacy in the barracks among the military," since he is perceived by some Iranian clergy as lacking religious education and credentials.

Khamenei was only a mid-level cleric when he succeeded Ayatollah Ruallah Khomeini, the father of the Iranian revolution, when Khomeini died in 1989. Khamenei's bona fides as an Islamic cleric were questioned when he was anointed, and suspicion among some in the clergy continues today.

"Those that are truly pious see the things that are taking place in Iran in the political realm are not reflective of their religious values," Sadjadpour says. "They see this widening income disparity between the haves and the have-nots, and many clerics don't respect Ayatollah Khamenei as a bona fide grand ayatollah."

Discontent among the clergy is worrisome for Khamenei, Sadjadpour says, but "what would be fatal for him would be dissent and discontent among the Revolutionary Guards." There is a "symbiotic relationship" between the supreme leader and the Guards, he says; the Ayatollah benefits politically and the Guards benefit economically.

Iran's Revolutionary Guard Corps, Sadjadpour says, "is garnering billion-dollar contracts as a result of their new found political prowess and the supreme buttressed politically."

"He may not have religious legitimacy, he may not have popular legitimacy, but he has a monopoly of coercion."

Khamenei may also be in the midst of engineering a fundamental shift in the Iranian power structure, having recently floated the possibility of abolishing the presidency, and switching to a parliamentary system.

The relationship between the supreme leader and Ahmadinejad has grown cold after Ahmadinejad forced the intelligence minister, a Khamenei protege, to resign earlier this year.

Khamenei promptly re-instated the minister, and the relationship between the two has not recovered according to Iran watchers.

soundoff (104 Responses)
  1. brimonidine

    brimonidine eye drops combigan bottle sizecombigan

    May 15, 2021 at 8:00 am | Reply
  2. chloroquine side effects

    what is chloroquine chloroquinolone

    May 7, 2021 at 4:43 pm | Reply
  3. dapoxetine

    buy priligy uk priligy price

    April 28, 2021 at 10:40 am | Reply
  4. counterfeit canadian drugs cialis

    canadian pharmacy cialis no prescription cialis viagra combination canadian pharmacy

    April 28, 2021 at 3:45 am | Reply
  5. erectile dysfunction pills

    erectile nerve regeneration why sudden erectile dysfunction

    April 27, 2021 at 11:41 pm | Reply
  6. alprostadil price in usa

    alprostadil urethral suppository otc alprostadil injection where to buy

    April 24, 2021 at 3:41 am | Reply
  7. generic tadalafil

    buy tadalafil tadalafil 40

    April 23, 2021 at 10:07 am | Reply
  8. zithromax order online

    nikkomycin z zithromax 250 mg dosage

    April 18, 2021 at 9:32 am | Reply
  9. cialis canadian pharmacy

    canadian viagra cialis how can i order cialis from a canadian pharmacy

    April 15, 2021 at 9:20 am | Reply
  10. vilitra 60mg vardenafil

    how do you take vardenafil 20 mg? vardenafil 40 mg generic

    April 12, 2021 at 4:31 am | Reply
  11. buy sildenafil from india

    how to get sildenafil prescription 20 mg sildenafil daily

    April 11, 2021 at 8:11 pm | Reply
  12. Free instagram Followers

    That is a good tip especially to those fresh to the blogosphere.
    Simple but very precise info… Thank you for sharing this one.
    A must read article!

    March 27, 2021 at 11:58 pm | Reply
  13. zortilonrel

    Amazing blog! Is your theme custom made or did you download it from somewhere? A theme like yours with a few simple tweeks would really make my blog stand out. Please let me know where you got your theme. Thanks a lot

    March 21, 2021 at 4:09 pm | Reply
  14. ClarkClurn

    cbccw ztuny fh5v

    March 1, 2021 at 4:43 am | Reply
  15. ClarkClurn

    l4xv3 mnupn 6sev

    February 28, 2021 at 3:15 pm | Reply

    Best view i have ever seen !

    February 16, 2021 at 6:07 pm | Reply
  17. Sheree Kilstofte

    January 28, 2021 at 10:00 pm | Reply
  18. Compare Cheap Auto Insurance Quotes

    At this aspect there doesn't are a single strategy to the situation of DWOCP (Driving While On Cell Phone) There are many states which can be
    attempting to have laws that might ban using a portable phone while driving.
    Friends love to share when they are in a position to save the their insurance or any product for that matter.

    The strongest indicator for low customer care with car insurance in British Columbia is clearly reflected in consumer feedback ratings.

    January 17, 2021 at 9:47 pm | Reply
  19. Lioba Castro

    Ser progenitores es todo un reto y elegir bien los juguetes mas. Ha sido un logro localizar esta web puesto que nos ha ayudado a escoger el gimnasio bebe con mucha facilidad

    December 17, 2020 at 3:31 am | Reply
  20. Rolf Marin

    An additional issue is that video games are usually serious anyway with the main focus on finding out rather than amusement. Although, it has an entertainment element to keep your kids engaged, every game is often designed to work towards a specific group of skills or curriculum, such as math concepts or scientific research. Thanks for your write-up.

    December 1, 2020 at 3:10 pm | Reply
  21. Larry Sugerak

    March 6, 2016 at 7:42 am | Reply
  22. anabolika bestellen

    You can train each muscle part once or twice. It does not really matter as long as you plan your routine properly. Your current routine needs changed, in my opinion, but whatever works for you is fine.. . By reading your question, I feel that you may think that the routine itself will make you big. This is surely not the case. Building muscle requires a combination of proper training and proper diet. You can train however you want to, but you will not build muscle unless you eat enough food, mostly in the form of protein. . . Muscle volume is just another way of saying muscle mass. Your routine could be used for building muscle, but you did not say how many reps or sets you are doing. The amount of sets are reps you do ultimately determines what result you will get from your training.

    August 29, 2013 at 7:16 am | Reply
  23. buy sustanon

    في متعة لفهم المواد المذكورة أعلاه غير عادية جدا ، ولقد استمتعت حقا قراءة بلوق والنقاط التي أعرب عنها. أود حقا أن تظهر مرة أخرى على أساس نموذجي ، آخر أكثر كثيرا في الموضوع. شكرا لتقاسم... الاستمرار في الكتابة!

    May 11, 2012 at 10:40 pm | Reply
  24. buy sustanon

    آخر مفيدة للغاية. شكرا لأخذ الوقت لتبادل الرأي الخاص معنا.

    May 11, 2012 at 4:04 pm | Reply
  25. DR LOVE

    Jesse you apology is accepted. dont get involved with the wrong crowd. open your legs wide and have fun in USA.

    November 13, 2011 at 2:54 pm | Reply
    • Guest 45

      Just what are you implying about THE USA DR Love?

      November 16, 2011 at 1:06 am | Reply
  26. Jesse

    I apologize to all of you and to Gi Joe I was wrong, I am a Persian and love Iran.

    November 13, 2011 at 2:53 pm | Reply
  27. MOT3A

    hi every body take it easy
    Jesse is right , we must all go to Iran and have the women to make motaa with them, motaa is like legal prostitution, Muslim in Iran practice legal hookering and prostitution and call it motaa, where you get a girl and marry here for 1 hour or one day sleep with them and divorce her ...only shiia practice this in Iran, also they allowed to marry their cousin and relatives, and some times their sisters , they go to place call najaf and karbala in Iraq and offer there daughters and wife's to the shiia mullah priests to sleep with them so they can go heaven, and get Bar aka ( blessing ),
    They pray by bending dogy style !!!!, USA CANT attack Iran , cause they must get red of Syria and Hizboallah the evil arms for Iran, Then help the Iranians resistant like Mujahedin Khalq to do the job.....USA should attack all Iran and warn Iraq and Syria that if they get involved they will be removed from the map.

    November 13, 2011 at 2:51 pm | Reply
    • Useless USA

      What fork are insinuating on Iran and rest Muslims of the world. Believe in monotheism and live a terrorist free life, Forget thta you are from the terrorist region – west (usa,israhell,............)

      November 16, 2011 at 6:16 am | Reply
    • Clara

      What's scarier, a poiicitlan who thinks his advisers can conjure Djinnis to further their power and influence .one a poiicitlan who claims we can achieve the Utopia of Marx, because we can do it right THIS TIME?

      May 22, 2012 at 12:45 pm | Reply
  28. DR LOVE- ahmad nejad= hitler

    Jesse you an Iranian idiots, sitting here in USA and attacking the voice of democracy and allying your self with the stupid Ahmad nejad and those shiia thugs like Hezbollah, Iran is evil as simple as that they have been evil since 5000 years ago , wage war against Greek and Babylonia killed ALI AND HUSSEIN KILLED OTTOMAN AND OMAR all dont by an idiots called khawareh, safween shiia who invited holako to destroy iraq, and invited forighn forces to control Egypt in fatimites time and now destroying the peace in Bahrain, Lebanon, iraq and helping Hamas and Hezbollah, Iran and Iraqi shiia thugs helping Syrian regime to kill civilians they are committing mass murders , Iran with nukes is like a mad dog. so shut your mouth ,cross your leg and leave the politics to those who know Iran very well, Obama is a weak ,he is a half Muslim, undermined Israel their minister, I agree with GI jOE and others THE TIME IS RUNNING OUT, attack before it is too late, dont wait for those Muslims idiots in Iran to strike first, I asked all the Arab coutires to side with USA
    and get red of the shiia and Iranians dont allow them to enter your countries they are the fifth stets, dont give them visa to come here in USA, watch what they do and report them to the FBI they are here as sleeping cells for terror, they send money to Hizboallah and other terrorists organizations remember never ever TRUST A SHIIA, Or IRANIAN.
    JESSE go play with your Barbi dolls, or I SHOULD SAY the Borqa , he-jab dolls
    VIVA USA AND DOWN WITH IRAN, DOWN WITH SYRIAN DOWN WITH HEZBOLLAH AND HAMAS, DOWN with IRAQI shiia thugs and all those who support them /

    November 13, 2011 at 2:41 pm | Reply
    • Puru

      Dude, you are delusional. Iran was evil 5000 years ago? Hahahahahahahahaha
      Your mom was evil for giving birth to a retard. Your dad has defective testis.

      November 15, 2011 at 1:52 am | Reply

    Jesse you an Iranian idiots, sitting here in USA and attacking the voice of democracy and allying your self with the stupid Ahmad nejad and those shiia thugs like Hezbollah, Iran is evil as simple as that they have been evil since 5000 years ago , wage war against Greek and Babylonia killed ALI AND HUSSEIN KILLED OTTOMAN AND OMAR all dont by an idiots called khawareh, safween shiia who invited holako to destroy iraq, and invited forighn forces to control Egypt in fatimites time and now destroying the peace in Bahrain, Lebanon, iraq and helping Hamas and Hezbollah, Iran and Iraqi shiia thugs helping Syrian regime to kill civilians they are committing mass murders , Iran with nukes is like a mad dog. so shut your mouth ,cross your leg and leave the politics to those who know Iran very well, Obama is a weak ,he is a half Muslim, undermined Israel their minister, I agree with GI jOE and others THE TIME IS RUNNING OUT, attack before it is too late, dont wait for those Muslims idiots in Iran to strike first, I asked all the Arab coutires to side with USA
    and get red of the shiia and Iranians dont allow them to enter your countries they are the fifth stets, dont give them visa to come here in USA, watch what they do and report them to the FBI they are here as sleeping cells for terror, they send money to Hizboallah and other terrorists organizations remember never ever TRUST A SHIIA, Or IRANIAN.
    JESSE go play with your Barbi dolls, or I SHOULD SAY the Borqa , he-jab dolls
    VIVA USA AND DOWN WITH IRAN, DOWN WITH SYRIAN DOWN WITH HEZBOLLAH AND HAMAS, DOWN with IRAQI shiia thugs and all those who support them /

    November 13, 2011 at 2:40 pm | Reply
  30. Disciple

    what if you could live forever?

    November 13, 2011 at 2:30 pm | Reply

    لماذا الشيعه...عملاء لايران ؟؟!!
    بقلم: الدكتور عمر عثمان البكر
    لطالما شغلتني اسئلة عجيبة وافكار رهيبة تشغل فكري واحاسيسي ووجداني وشعوري وتجعلني اقف مستغربا ومتحيرا من سر ارتباط العمالة والخيانة للشيعه بايران بل مما يثير الريبة والاستغراب هو سر تعلق الشيعه بايران تعلقا.... اعمى ابصارهم وشوه افكارهم واستخف بعقولهم .. ولكن قبل ان نستغرب ونتحير ونتعجب ؟؟دعونا ننظر الى الشيعي مهما كانت دراسته وثقافته وعمره ومكان نشأته.. ونقارن بين عقول البشر الاسوياء العاديين وبين عقلية الشيعي وتطرفه واعتقاداته وطريقة عباداته وتأدية طقوس دينه ؟ !!!!
    وحتى لا نكون متطرفين بنظر البعض ولا نثير غضب البعض علينا فلنبعد عن باقي الاديان واعتقاداتها وناخذ فقط الدين الشيعي الذي ينسب نفسه ظلما.. الى الدين الاسلامي الحنيف ...الواضح العقائد والتشريعات بسوره المحكمات في قراننا الكريم. فالشيعي يؤمن بكل ما يقوله له (معمموه) حتى وان كانو خونة او كذابين او عملاء للاجانب او لصوص او دجالين او فاسقين مثل الناجي وغيره ...والشيعي يصدق بالخرافات والغرائب بدون ان يستخدم عقله فعندما يسمع احد معمميه يقول له قصة مفبركة وغريبة وينسبها لائمام من أئمتهم نراه يصدق ويصيح بصوت عالي (الله المصلي على محمد... وال محمد) ونحن نفرح لكل من يصلي على الرسول وال بيته الطيبين الطاهرين ولكننا نحزن لاي انسان ومنهم الشيعي لانه يصدق خرافة لا يقبلها العقل؟ولا يقبلها منطق؟
    فهو يصدق ان ابو طالب عنده ثدي يرضع به الرسول؟؟؟ ويصدق بان الاسد عنده مشكلة عائلية (زوجته معسرة بالولادة) فيطأطىء(الاسد) راسه ويعرض مشكلته على الحسين ليحلها له !! والى اخر هذه الخزعبلات؟؟ ويصدق الشيعي ايضا وبدون تشغيل عقله ان علي ابن ابي طالب يوزع بطاقات الجنه للشيعه؟ ويصدق الشيعي ان المسيرات المرثونية لها اجرعظيم وان الله سبحانه يحظر بنفسه هذه المسيرات؟؟؟والكثير الكثير الذي لا يسعه هذا المقال؟؟
    فاذا كانت هذه الغرائب والعجائب التى لا يقبلها عقل سوي ...يصدقوها؟؟ وقد قيل بالامثال.... حدث العاقل بما لايعقل فان صدق فلا عقل له!!!! فكم من الخرافات صدقوها ومازالو يصدقون .... بعد الاحتلال وعدهم رؤوساء احزابهم الدينية ورغم عمالتهم للمحتل.. وصدقو وعودهم ومع انهم لم يحققو لهم شيئا من وعودهم الكثيرة ومازالو يصدقوهم؟؟؟ وزاد فقرهم وذلهم وتشرذمهم ومازالو يصدقوهم وعندما تظاهرو بساحة التحرير بالعراق مطالبين بحقوقهم ... خوفوهم باندساس البعثيين بينهم ويعيدوهم للمربع الا ول وما ادري انا هم باي مربع الان ؟حتى يخافون من العودة للمربع الاول؟ و فعلاخافو وتركو التظاهر خوفا على فقدان مربعهم الحالي ...ولا ادري هل المربع الحالي الذي حصلو عليه (المقصود به هو) اللطم واحياء ثارات عاشوراء والبكاء والعويل..فاذا كانو خائفين على هذا المربع فلعمري ان المربع الاول احسن بكثير من المربع و المثلث و المستطيل الحالي وحتى الدائرة الحالية؟؟؟ اعود واقول اذا الشيعه يصدقون هؤلاء الكذابين برغم مرور ثمان سنوات عجاف ولم يحققوا لهم شيئا مما وعدوهم به .....ولكن حققوا لهم... الفساد والبطالة وتدهور الاقتصاد وشيوع الجريمة والتخلف وانعدام الخدمات ....ومع هذا مازالو يصدقون بوعودهم وباكاذيبهم؟؟؟ .. فبعد كل هذه السنين وبعد انكشاف زيف ودجل وفساد مجلس الدواب العراقي ومازالو يمنون النفس بوصال ليلى .... اذن هكذا نفسية ماذا تتوقعون منها ؟؟...
    فكيف لا يصدقون الخميني عندما ضحك على عقول كثير من المسلمين وتصوره انسان سوي صادق يحب الدين الاسلامي وخائف على تعاليمه وسيحرر القدس مرورا ببغداد وكربلاء ..ولكن الله سبحانه وتعالى فضحه بفضائح ايران غيت ومع كل الفضائح بقي الشيعه يصدقوه ويطلقون عليه الامام!!!! ووصف العجم امريكا الشيطان الاكبر واتضحت الايام انها شريكتهم وحليفتهم بتخريب واحتلال العراق وافغانستان وبقي حبهم لايران وكشفت الاحداث اتفاق ايران مع القاعدة ولها ضلع في تفجيرات المناطق الشيعيه لخلق البلبلة في العراق وبقت محبتهم لايران؟ وايران تسرق نفط حقل مجنون العراقي وايران تبزل اراضيها المالحة باتجاه اراضي البصرة وايران جففت روافدها ومنعت استفادة شيعة الجنوب منها ؟؟ وايران تقتل السنه والشيعه معا في ايران؟؟ وايران تطمع وتتأمر على الدول الخليجية العربية؟ وايران تريد تخريب الاقتصاد والحضارة العربية وأيران تتامر على البحرين ؟!! وبرغم ذلك مازالو يودون ويحبون ايران ؟؟؟!!
    وايران تصنع المتفجرات والعبوات الناسفة واللاصقة ؟؟ويبقى حب ايران قد ملك قلب الشيعه ؟؟ ومجلس الدواب العراقي ينسى ويتناسى مصائب وفقر وبطالة وجوع الشعب العراقي ولكنه يثور وينفعل مع الشيعه البحرينين لانهم اداة ايران؟؟ و يبقى تعلقهم بايران يثير الاستغراب والشك ؟
    ايران تشجع المظاهرات بالبحرين وتقمع مظاهرات طهران!والشيعه في العراق ولبنان والسعودية والكويت يؤيدون ايران ويشجعون تخريبها للبحرين ؟؟!!! ويفرحون لتخريب البحرين!! عجيب ....غريب؟؟!! هل العمالة والخيانة والتخريب وعدم الاخلاص للوطن الام هي من سمات الشيعي؟؟ فتاريخه منذ القدم يتسم بالتخريب والقتل وسفك الدماء؟! فهم الذين قتلوا عليا بن ابي طالب وعمر الفاروق وهم الذين قتلو الحسين والان يتباكون عليه!! فطبيعتهم الاجرام والخيانة والعمالة ...ابحثو بكتب التاريخ عن القرامطة وعن الفاطمية والعبيدية وعن خيانات الطوسي وابن العلقمي وعن شيعة العراق وشيعة لبنان وشيعة الكويت وشيعة البحرين وشيعة مصر ..في كل هذه الدول تلاحظون مقدار المسامحة والتعاون معهم وتسهيل طقوسهم برغم خزعبلاتها ويصمتون تقية وهم يعرفون انهم ياخذون اكثر من استحقاقهم ...ولكنهم بعد حين من الزمان وخاصه في حالة تمكنهم ووجود من يساعدهم ينقلبون الى اعداء وجواسيس وخونة بل مجرمين عتاة لا يتورعون عن ذبح الطفل السني (خاصة) وسلقه وارساله الى ذويه والاعتداء على شرف الحرائر وعلى الشيخ والعجوز ويذبحوهم بدم بارد كما فعلوا بالعراق وبالبحرين وفي غرب ايران وكثير من الدول المبتلية بهم!!
    حاول كثير من علماء السنة الاخيار التعامل معهم باللين بغية نصحهم وارشادهم ولكن ظهر لهم انهم بشر لا عقول لهم وخير دواء لهم هو استئصالهم من هذه الامة لانهم وباء خطير معدي سرطاني لايفيده دواء..
    أسال الله العظيم ان يديم نعمة الاسلام على المسلمين وان يخلصنا من هذا الابتلاء العظيم وينقي الاسلام من هولاء الشيعه الانجاس

    November 13, 2011 at 2:25 pm | Reply
  32. Patriotic American

    The People of America should wake up and see how our government is turning us into Bullies. Wise countries like China and Russia has stand out and economically progressing and we are into economic crisis. We fight for the 99th percent of Americans rather than the 1% interest.

    November 12, 2011 at 12:50 pm | Reply
    • Chris, Austin

      Your syntax and grammar do not indicate American English.

      Ask Viet Nam if China is a bully.

      Ask Georgia if Russia is.

      November 12, 2011 at 3:13 pm | Reply
      • Saritha

        Remember, too, that the 2008 US election was baialslcy a statistical tie. In Iran, it was obvious to everyone that the government didn't even bother to count the votes but just announced an arbitrary result, awarding landslide percentages to Ahmadinejad in every district in the country, even in areas where big majorities had obviously voted for the opposition.

        May 4, 2014 at 3:49 pm |
    • J.PollardJooSpy

      Hey, I'm getting out of jail soon – thanks bebe! When I do, I'll be a big time hero in racist israel.

      I'll retire with millions of dollars, even though some true American Patriots want me shot.

      But hey, there smucks! The only game in town is OUR zionist devil worshiping game. When we zionist greedy bankers cause hyper inflation and the dollar crashes, I'll still be a rich ex spy.

      I don't care on flip for America. America is overcrowed with cattle/goyim, anyway.

      Thanks Obama, for setting me free!

      Yipppppeeeeeee! Spying for the zionist does pay off!!

      November 12, 2011 at 4:52 pm | Reply
  33. thoughtfortheday

    I think we should help iran develop a Neutron Bomb--and then help them test it in the center of their country........That will be a religious experience for the eyeahora..

    November 12, 2011 at 10:26 am | Reply
  34. Lliam

    Nuclear air burst over Tehran at a sufficient altitude to inflict an electromagnetic pulse with a nominal range of 480 miles.

    November 11, 2011 at 10:05 pm | Reply
  35. Scrilla Villa

    If you nuke any country in the MIddle East, the most you would hit is a camel or a tent.

    November 11, 2011 at 11:20 am | Reply
    • Giao

      Here is the entire text of Ayatollah Khamenei’s major plcoiy speech of yesterday with regard to Iran US relation for those they haven’t read his entire speech translated by GOSCIn the name of God, the most Merciful, the most Compassionate.(Opening remarks in Arabic)In prayers about the month of Ramadan, which appear in the Sahife-ye Sajjadiyeh (a book containing the prayers of the fourth Shi’a Imam) and other prayers exclusive to this month, some features and characteristics have been mentioned in regard each of which need to be elaborated upon.In one case, this month has been mentioned as the month of repentance. I will say several sentences regarding this month of repentance. The phrase the “month of Islam” has been mentioned in the Sahife-ye Sajjadiyeh. In this case, the word “Islam” means the same thing mentioned in a holy verse (words rendered in Arabic) which talks about submitting one’s heart and soul and giving in to the divine will, order and sharia.In another case, this month has been described as a month in which there is a cleansing element which cleanses mankind. The word “cleanse” was also used as an infinitive which means a month of being cleansed from impurities.The month of Ramadan has also been described as a month of purity. For example, when someone puts a valuable metal such as gold into a kiln in order to separate it from other metals with which it is mixed, it is called purification. In the case of Ramadan, it means to separate the pure human nature from impurities and the unclean. These are some of the descriptions and features used to describe this month.As far as people are concerned, the month of Ramadan represents a month of the year in which people are praying and worshipping around the clock. In other words, Islamic laws provide an opportunity for us people who are surrounded and restricted by materialistic issues, to pray at prayer times at dawn, noon, afternoon, and evening. It is like a warning alarm and a kind of seclusion to brighten our heart and soul. This is what prayer does. Daily prayer times have been arranged in a way so that we are not drowned, and to escape from the imprisonment of materialism for a while, refresh ourselves and to think a little bit about morality. It has been arranged so that we don’t drown in materialism.It seems that throughout the year, the month of Ramadan creates such an opportunity for us. It allows the human spirit and divine spirit to breathe. This month of self-discipline is an opportunity for our spirit to escape for a while from the imprisonment of the materialist world surrounding us, to breathe and to become bright. The holy Islamic sharia has designed the month of Ramadan for such goals.Well, it is an opportunity. Among the aforementioned features, all of which are important, I found the issue of repentance more attractive to discuss with you who are officials of this country. This is a month of repentance.Repentance means stop treading the wrong path, doing wrong things, having a wrong thought. By inabah (Arabic, religious term) we mean referring to God, going back to God. The nature of repentance and inabah has a meaning within itself. When we say come back from the wrong path, it means you should recognize the wrong path. This is very important. As we go on we usually ignore our mistakes and wrongdoings. We don’t pay attention to our weak points. By us, I mean us as individuals and a society, our nation, our party, our wing. The nature of anything associated with an individual human being is usually not paid attention to. Therefore, others should inform us of our flaws. If we would be aware of our shortcomings and reform them then there would be no need for others to tell us about them. The first step for repentance and inabah is to pay attention to the root of the flaws and find out what we are doing wrong, where our mistake, fault, sin source from. We should start with ourselves and then social circles. But first we should evaluate ourselves to see find out about our mistakes. This is everyone’s duty, ordinary individuals like us who can have many flaws, faults and sins and even outstanding people, God’s pious human beings and even the prophets. The same is true with them. They needed repentance, too. There is a story associated with the prophet of Islam (Mohammad), peace be upon him and his household. This hadith (narration from Prophet Mohammad) has been narrated by Sunnis and Shi’is both. It quotes the prophet, saying (Arabic): “My heart is filled with fog and clouds- (he explains) the same way that a cloud covers the sun and the moon and creates darkness and covers that bright reflection- and I repent 70 times per day.” The prophet, that divine spirit, that pure nature (used to repent). There is another narration where Imam Sadeq (sixth Shi’i imam), peace be upon him, has said the prophet used to repent 70 times per day without having committed any sins. The prophet is innocent, why would he repent? Late Fayz, has said: (Arabic) In streets, markets and routine life the prophet could neglect something for a second. What may happen in our life all the time could have happened to him for a moment. He could have been busy with some permissible deed and, therefore, subject to repentance. Therefore, this (repentance) is not just for us. It’s for everyone.In other words, I and you who hold a responsibility and run some of the country’s affairs, or have influence over certain social issues in the country, have a bigger obligation and greater responsibility to repent before God. We should be very careful. Sometimes an offence may take place in bodies under your or my supervision. If we have carried out this offence, we are responsible. If a violation has taken place because for example we have failed to make an announcement or recruit a certain person, or we have been negligent in dealing with these offences, (Words rendered in Arabic) So, one can conclude that during the month of Ramadan we should do our utmost to correct our behaviour. We should correct our mind, words, and deeds. We should identify our faults and eliminate them.What should this correction be based on? This should be based on piety. (Words rendered in Arabic meaning that fasting should be for piety) So, these attempts we make during the month of Ramadan should serve to improve piety. I have made a note here about what I would like to say about piety. When we speak about piety, a person starts thinking about observing the Sharia laws such as praying, payment of the religious taxes, and not to lie. Of course, all of these are important. However, piety has also other aspects which we usually neglect.The prayer “Sharif” is about those aspects of piety. The prayer goes like this (prayer in Arabic). It asks God to dress him/her with clothes of the pure and adorn her/him with virtues of the pious. What is this dress of the pure? It explains (words in Arabic): The clothes of the pure means spreading justice and (words in Arabic) swallowing anger and (words in Arabic) putting out fires, fires that start between the members of a society. This means piety.(Words in Arabic) Try to gather individuals, who are from your tribe but have been isolated. This is one of the aspects of piety which is mentioned in the Sharif prayer. It is a very important prayer. I believe all officials should read this prayer and pay attention to its meaning. It is very educational. (Words in Arabic) And also instead of spying and fanning flames, and causing discord, one should bring reconciliation among Muslim brothers. This means piety.Note that these are our today’s issues. These are all our issues, spreading justice, and that includes administrative justice, judicial justice, economic justice, justice in selecting, justice in allocating resources and opportunities between groups, geographical justice. These are very important issues. These are all our needs. Spreading justice is the most important aspect of piety. This aspect holds a higher position than fasting on a hot summer day.A story says: When a ruler, the ruler could be any on you with authority over your lives, administers justice for one day, he has in fact prayed for 70 years. These are very important issues. They highlight the importance of justice and just behaviour. To swallow your anger: here we are talking about when you are with friends. (Verse in Arabic) Anger against enemy has been approved in the Koran. Anger against an enemy, who is against you and your identity, is considered a holy act. However, showing anger among the pious and towards those, whom we ought to treat in a Muslim fashion, is harmful. Making decisions, talking and working when angry, is harmful and is usually accompanied with mistakes. unfortunately, this is how many of us behave. To stop this anger, which causes deviation and mistakes in thought and action, is one of the aspects of piety.Some people have the mission to create political and factional discord, and I can see it happening in our country. Some people want to create conflict among various individuals and factions and cause friction among members of different factions. They want to create conflict, they enjoy doing it.This goes against piety. Piety means curbing destruction in the realm of humanity, ethics and spirituality, just as you would in the material domain. And also, (Verse in Arabic), maximum absorption and minimum repulsion. Of course, the criteria are values and principles. Not all humans are at the same level when their faith is concerned. We have, among us, those whose faith is weak but also those who have strong beliefs. We have to compromise. We cannot repel those with weak faith and only pay attention to those who have strong beliefs. We should also consider the weak. Those who regard themselves as strong believers should make allowances for those who are not. They should not repel them. They should try to bring to their senses those who, are part of the society but have been isolated due to neglect. They should advise them, direct them, show them the path and bring them back.These are fundamental issues. Now, this is called piety and these are ways of repenting. However, the interesting point is that fasting in the month of Ramadan is a collective activity. it is not an individual activity. In other words, we are all fasting, we are all involved and we, the Islamic ummah, are all sitting at the Iftar (fast-breaking) table. Imagine what would happen in the world of Islam and in the country, if we all regarded ourselves the addressees of the book and tradition and listened to and acted upon the advice that was given.We must appreciate this month. And that means that we should repent and purge ourselves. Well, this is the main thing I wanted to say in this meeting.As far the country’s current affairs are concerned, the President gave a very detailed, good and useful report. If we intend to make a correct analysis of the country’s current situation, we have to start by saying that there Islamic Iran is faced with an old opposing front which was created by a certain group. It’s an old front. These struggles, quarrels and fronts have existed for the past 32 years. It’s nothing new.Of course, the front which is opposing us has changed. But we haven’t changed. We are still using the same words, have the same ideals and going down the same path. We have found a path which we are quickly going down. We have indicated our goals. They were outlined very clearly from the very beginning in the Imam’s (Khomeini) comments. We are making progress as much as we can. But the other front has undergone changes. Some people have left or joined it.Two phenomena can be seen in the current lineup. One is that our opposing front is weaker than before. I mean that the front opposing us has got weaker and weaker. The second phenomenon is that the front we have created is getting stronger. These two phenomena can be proved. It’s not a slogan. It’s based on realities. I would like to make a short point about the front opposing us.What does the opposing front mean? In its propaganda, this front calls itself the world community. This is a big lie. They don’t represent the world community at all. They are a few countries. The main axis of this front is the Zionist regime and the United States of America. The rest either follow their (the US and Israel’s) policies, feel obligated to follow them, or are very weak countries who can’t do anything. Many of them do not agree with the two main axes (US and Israel). This isn’t the case only today and it has been the case over past years. Forget about the claims because the reality is what I’m saying.Now, based on what criterion do we believe these two government or entities to be our main enemies in the opposing front? What is the nature of this opposition? There are two kinds of opposition. One is fundamental antagonism and another is superficial antagonism. Superficial antagonism is when two countries have differences over their borders, trade issues and some policies.Fundamental antagonism is opposition to the existence of something. This means that two countries who don’t recognize each other’s existence. This is how we feel about the Zionist regime. We don’t recognize that regime’s existence. We believe it to be a fake regime which has been imposed and is like a deadly disease which the Middle East region doesn’t need. Without a doubt, this disease will be destroyed. I mean there is no doubt that it will not remain. At any rate, we are against it (Israel’s) existence and identity. That regime is also against the existence of the Islamic system. They would like Iran to be ruled by a monarchist system. But they hate the Islamic system. This is what fundamental animosity means.As far as the US is concerned, the United States’ approach toward the Islamic system is one based on non-recognition. We have fully realized this over the years. Of course, they themselves call for a change of behaviour. The change of behaviour they want – and which they don’t always necessary emphasize on – is in fact a negation of identity. It means that the main behaviours which are based on Islam have to change. Our approach toward America is one based on which we negate its arrogant nature. The American regime and government should be like other governments. As far as we are concerned, we reject the US’ arrogant nature and the fact that it is a superpower dominating the world. We don’t accept such a thing. This is fundamental antagonism.This fundamental opposition may sometime be active or passive. This fundamental opposition may also exist with other countries in the world, but in a passive form for various reasons.The opposition between these two governments (Iran and the USA) is an active one. This is a word on the opposition front. This opposition front is weakening. If we compare its (America’s) economic, political and social status as well as its influence and presence in the world with 30 years ago, we will realize that it has weakened greatly.There are some points that I have written here. First, our opposing front lacks popular support in the world, i.e. you do not find any country in the world where its people would support the regime of the United States or the usurping Zionist regime. They do not enjoy popular support.Even countries whose governments support them (the USA and Israel) with zeal, people oppose them (the USA and Israel). It is interesting that many of these people are non-Muslims. Today, you saw in newspapers that the head of the Zionist regime had gone to visit a European country, and the people – according to the news – had gathered in thousands asking him (head of Israel) to get lost and leave the country. The same applies everywhere. Wherever they go, they face the same situation, i.e. they do not enjoy popular support. The status of the Zionist regime is clear. But the American regime, despite all its political influence and use of force is still unpopular among nations.Apart from all this, they are hated by nations. The front opposing us is not just unloved, but is also hated. Their flags and pictures are burned and their dummies are stepped on. This is their situation. They (Americans) have a bitter experience of their military operations. America has a bitter experience of its operations in Afghanistan and Iraq. They have failed. Concerning the Palestinian issue, the political efforts by America has led nowhere. They have failed. The Zionists’ failure during the 33-day war (against Lebanon) and their attack against Gaza is clear to everyone.Our opposing front is in a bad economic situation. Despite all their efforts, they did not succeed in overcoming their economic recession. They say that they have made progress. But the truth is that nothing positive has yet been done and they are under economic pressure. Their measures including injection of large amounts of money into financial institutions have not yet been effective and they are still in an adverse economic situation.They have failed in their Middle East policies in Palestine, Syria, and Lebanon. Their grave mistakes have made their governments incapable of decision-making. They are in a state of confusion. The Americans truly do not know what to do in Afghanistan today. They have differences among themselves. They cannot make a decision that would surely be in their interest. If they leave Afghanistan, they will face scandal and misery. If they stay in Afghanistan, they may fail and become miserable again. The same is more or less true in the case of Iraq.Iraq is similar. They do not know what to do in the case of Iraq. They interfere and make attempts but they do not get anywhere. Their officials’ self-confidence has sharply slumped as compared to the past. Compare today’s America (reception interrupted for two minutes)I do not claim that we have reached the level of advanced countries in terms of scientific progress. No. The point is we are accelerating forward. This is great news for a nation. If we continue to make progress at the same pace, in no time our nation and youth will achieve expected levels of advancement. The same is true about progress in technology and development in the country.Certain statistics were presented by the esteemed president here. These are correct figures. Great works are being done in the fields of construction, industry, energy, transportation and other fields. Compared to 30 years ago, when we started, and even 20 years ago, a great progress has been made. However, the country has not just made progress in material fields. The same is true in social and spiritual fields. Iran enjoys high spirits. Our youth have great incentives.The political arena is active. When there is an election, 40m people take part in it and 25m people choose (the president). These are important phenomena. Yes, bitter incidents took place following the elections based on their own reasons. Each incident was caused for certain reasons. But, the presence of people (at the polling stations) is a great issue and important development. Our opponents expected that 30 years after the revolution — and after 30 elections — people would gradually lose interest and enthusiasm in the elections. However, the election as a serious event was welcomed by the public. This is progress.Iran enjoys great support among Islamic countries. Our senior officials face the excitement and sensation of people in whatever country they travel to. The same does not apply to other countries. This is not particular to this time. The same has been true since the revolution. Wherever the officials of the country — including the president- – travelled, they were welcomed by people. Some of the countries that they travelled to did not have any commonality with us in terms of language, race, and geographical location.Nevertheless, people gather and express their respect (to Iranian senior officials). The Islamic Republic of Iran enjoys the same level of support — if not more — with world people. We have great hope for the future. We never expected to achieve this level of development in such a short time. With the grace of God Almighty, our youth today do things in the field of science and technology that were unimaginable to those who planned for the future of the country 20 to 25 years ago. This has been achieved today. This increases our hope in the future.We have successful experience in political fields. Contrary to the opposing front which has failed in the Middle East, Iraq, Afghanistan and various regions, we have had successful experience wherever we have gone to. Iran has even been successful wherever it felt that it was duty bound to go. This is confessed by everyone. This is why our opponents are very unhappy.One of our successes is in the fact that our opponents are captured in the hatred of the world. Therefore, two phenomena are outstanding, i.e. the image of our opponents is descending and ours is ascending. You may present a correct analysis for everything in the country when you approach the affairs from this angle.We think, analyse, and plan based on this line up. The enemy does the same. The enemy sits and plans on how to treat the Islamic Republic of Iran. It plans for every eventuality from both defensive and offensive perspectives. We have our own planning against the enemy. We should learn all this. We should proceed together in practice, as it has been so thus far.I will give you a quick idea of what the enemy does. Its plans are as follows: economic pressure, military threat, and psychological war in order to influence public opinion inside the country and at the international level. These are what they are doing, i.e. creating political disruptions and sabotage inside the country. Undoubtedly, there are certain centres inside the country that are inspired by the enemy. They do certain things under the inspiration and guidance of the enemy. Satans refer to their masters to be guided (previous sentence in Arabic).Along with all these activities, the Americans do not give up the slogan of negotiations. They have imposed sanctions against Iran, issued resolutions, imposed unilateral sanctions and threatened Iran militarily, at the same time they constantly say that they are ready to talk with Iran.The strategies of the enemy are not new. We should bear in mind that none of these measures are unprecedented. Sanctions have been imposed on Iran for 30 years. Threats of military action have existed during all rounds (of presidencies) before this one. I’ll explain to you and I am aware of them more than anyone else.During Clinton’s presidency, as I recall, the threat of military action was so strong that the esteemed president of the time used to tell me that we should be mindful not to allow the developments in the country be destroyed by a military attack. This meant that there was a significant possibility of attack at the time.During the presidency term, before the ninth round, (the eighth presidency term) military threats were sometimes so severe and repetitive by the enemy that the officials used to get very fearful. We held meetings, we have many memories of those days, I have made notes about those days.Military threats have always existed. It was not the case that threats were never made. Propaganda against Iran existed since the beginning of the Revolution. They levelled accusations against Iran over anything they could. They made accusations against Imam (Khomeini), people, communities and Friday prayers. All were subject to accusations and insults in the world by using the massive facilities that they had at their disposal. This is not limited to today. Threats exist now, but threats were no less in the past, in some cases they were even more severe.Sabotage inside the country is not limited to today. In the year 1382 (2003) after the Iraq issue, and the occupiers’ attack on Iraq, if you remember there was mayhem inside the country for a few days. For some reason they came out…(Pauses and changes tack) The black lady (Condoleezza Rice), the advisor to the American President at the time, who then became the American Secretary of State, explicitly announced that America supports any uprising or unrest in Iran. She explicitly announced this.They were hopeful and thought that something was happening in Tehran. This goes back to 1382, but even before then, similar incidents took place. In 1388 (2009) similar incidents also took place, everyone remembers them now and witnessed what happened.The threats that exist today are nothing new. I want to say a word regarding each and every one of these instances.But concerning negotiations and what is said about it, the offer of talks is nothing new to Iran; and Iran has always rejected talks. There is a clear reason for this, and that is that talks under threat and pressure cannot be called talks. If one side intends to act like a superpower, threatening the other side, putting it under pressure, and imposing sanctions on it — and showing an iron hand — and at the same time offering talks, this cannot be called talks. We will not hold such talks with anybody. This is how America has always called for talks.We have two short-term experiences. One was talks over Iraq. During my public speech, I said that we accept to take part in the talks. The officials then held the negotiations. The other was during previous governments. The Americans sent a message to us and said that they had an important security issue to discuss with us. The (Iranian) government accordingly sent a delegation and held two to three rounds of talks.These are our experiences of talks (with the Americans). According to our experience, when the Americans are unable to present a logical reasoning, they start bullying the other side. Since bullying has no effect on the Islamic Republic, they unilaterally announce that the talks are over. What sort of talks are these. We have this experience too. The same happened in both cases.Concerning the first case, I could already anticipate from the quality of the talks what the conclusion would be. I used to receive reports of the meetings. When they held two to three meetings, I told the Ministry of Foreign Affairs to stop the talks. But before they could take their move, the Americans unilaterally stopped the talks. This is how they are.Therefore, while the esteemed president and others say that we are always ready for talks, this is true but not with America. (People chanting: “God is Great, Khamene’i is the leader, death to those who are against the vali-e faqih, death to America, Britain, hypocrites, atheists and Israel).The reason is that, contrary to an ordinary negotiator, America does not enter the talks as an honest interlocutor. It enters the talks like a superpower, and we will not negotiate with a superpower-looking figure.They (Americans) should forget this superpower attitude. They should put threats aside. They should put sanctions aside. They should not consider a specific objective and final for talks. I announced this a few years ago in Fars, in Shiraz while addressing the public. I said we have not sworn not to hold any talks forever. It’s because of such issues that we do not hold talks. They are not negotiators. They want to bully. (For example) just like (the story where) a rascal who liked honey and went to a shop and asked how much was a jar of honey. He said 100 tumans. Then he squeezed the guy’s (shopkeeper’s) hand hard and the poor shopkeeper got scared and said whatever you say. He said 30 tumans and the shopkeeper agreed. This is not a negotiation. This is not making a deal. If they can squeeze others’ hands to make them change 100 tumans to 30 tumans, it doesn’t mean the Islamic Republic would accept such a thing. It (Iran) will not accept these pressures. It (Iran) will respond to all pressures in its own way. (Crowd chanting slogans)They should not use bullying. They should come down the rotten ladder of superpower attitude and then there won’t be a problem. But as long as they are doing so, it would be impossible (to hold talks).Now, regarding the nuclear issue. One of the concerns is the nuclear issue. Fuel production cycle is our right. We will not give up this right and will not stop. This is our right. We want to produce fuel hopefully. We need thousands of megawatts of nuclear fuel. Nuclear power plants should be established and the fuel for these plants should be produced domestically. The country won’t manage its affairs if we are to depend on foreign countries to feed these power plants. We have to produce it domestically.Therefore, it is our right and we will pursue it. In response to this they say Iran need nuclear fuel and we would provide it, we will set up an international bank for it and provide it. This is nonsense. These are meaningless and unreasonable words. Regarding the 20-per cent fuel swap, their level of honesty became clear. We needed 20-per cent (enriched) fuel for this small power plant. This is something normal. They do this around the world. We had bought it some ten, 16 years ago. There is no problem. As soon as they realized Iran needed it, they started playing games and turning this into an issue.In my opinion this was a big mistake by the USA and the West. They made a mistake by acting so regarding the 20-percent fuel issue. First, by doing so they encouraged us to pursue the 20-percent fuel. We didn’t want to. We didn’t have the intention of producing 20-percent fuel. The 3.5-percent (enriched fuel) was enough for us. But by doing so they encouraged us, they forced us, they made us understand that we had to go for 20 percent and we did so. This was their first mistake. Their second mistake was that they proved it to the entire world and made it clear that the USA and others who can produce this fuel are not trustable for relying on them for fuel. Because as soon as it would be needed they will list their claims and demands and say you have to fulfil those to get the fuel. This is not a deal. Therefore, regarding the nuclear issue they don’t have anything to say. They don’t have any logic. We have found the path and we are moving forward and hopefully we will continue the same path.Regarding the military threat! It is not very like them to make such a stupid mistake. But if there were to be such a threat, everyone should know that the scope of such a confrontation will not be limited to our region. It will spread further. (Crowd chanting slogans)On the issue of the anti-Iranian campaign launched by America, I think that the enemy is taking the most unfair action. This is while the Americans are the worst violators of human rights themselves. That is the reality of it. When they are pursuing their interests, the lives of innocent human beings will become worthless for them. When it comes to them, they become demanding. When the occupiers attacked Iraq and Basra, they used 10-tonne bombs, the Americans, themselves called them the mother of all bombs, 10 tonnes! They killed many civilian people, women and children in Basra and elsewhere. In the same days, a few American pilots were arrested, the Bathist Iraqi regime interviewed them on TV, the Americans’ loud cries were raised saying that this was against international regulations and POWs should not be interviewed like this.They have double-standards and judgments, they are the biggest violators of democracy. In many countries the Americans have disrupted the obvious democratic election results, for example in Gaza and the Hamas government. There are other examples of this which happened in the past that I do not want to mention here. They are worst of all, but that is how it is.What needs to be acknowledged is that these attacks and enmities are not new and the Islamic Republic of Iran has certain policies against them. As for sanctions, fortunately officials have adopted very strong and appropriate policies. I asked the respected president for the economic ministers to come and provide a report. They provided me with a report on the measures they have taken against the UN Security Council resolution i.e. the sanctions and then the unilateral sanctions by America and Europe.Their decisions are very appropriate, and hopefully the decision by the officials is to turn sanctions into opportunities. In fact, the situation needs to be turned into opportunities. We need to increase domestic production and strengthen it. We need to get used to the consumption of domestic products, and improving the quality of our products. Of course, in this case, the government officials and lawmakers have a heavy responsibility. Regarding the management of imports, I advised the government officials and stress it now, too. I don’t say that imports should be stopped all together, because imports are necessary in some areas, but they should be properly managed. In some areas imports should be banned and in other areas they should be allowed. Imports should be carried out through management. Of course, the respected government officials said that the laws which have been ratified by the Majlis do not allow us to stop imports.I ask them to solve this issue; if in fact there are laws which stop the government preventing imports, they should amend this law so that imports can be managed. Domestic products should be increased, wise policies should be adopted on many issues, plcoiy is very important, applying wisdom when making decisions is extremely important, decisions should be wise and brave. Wisdom should not be interpreted as a sign of fear, and retreat. Wisdom should be accompanied by bravery.Prophets were also the wisest human beings. One of the anecdotes of the prophet (of Islam) says: (words in Arabic) no prophet has been chosen by God before he reached the highest level of wisdom. Even if the same prophet, has carried out the most Jihad acts, struggle and took most risks. I mean bravery should be accompanied by wisdom, determination, no hesitation, and with consideration to the horizons. At the same time unity and sympathy should be maintained as well.I emphasize unity here. Unity and cooperation among the country’s officials is an obligation. Deliberate objection to it is considered against the Shar’ia today, especially when it is done at higher levels.Everyone should be careful. Enemies want to create a major issue out of trivial differences. You should not let that happen. It is not the case that any difference between two officials or two institutions is considered to be a disaster. After all, it is possible that the Majlis takes one approach in an area and the government takes a different view. They may have different tastes and opinions. This is not a disaster.Which of the Revolution’s main figures, supporters and enemies predicted 40 years ago that such a thing (Revolution) would happen in the country? Such a major incident! Such a high act! Who could have guessed? But it happened due to our reliance on Almighty God, strong determination, not fearing death, not fearing failure. We could have progress in the name of God and by reliance on God. It will be the same hereafter.Dear God, bestow your kindness and blessings upon the great imam’s (Ayatollah Khomeyni’s) spirit who put us on this path (Crowd chanting amen). God, give the dear martyrs the best of ranks (Crowd chanting amen). God, help the Iranian nation achieve its big goals and wishes (Crowd chanting amen). God, cut the enemy’s arm off this nation and this country (Crowd chanting amen). God, bestow your blessings and good wishes upon all those who serve the system and the people sincerely (Crowd chanting amen).

      May 23, 2012 at 10:13 pm | Reply
  36. RCDC

    We should only act in self defense. Thou shall not kill is in the ten commandments. And an eye for an eye is on the old testament. We should fear and obey the word of God. God punish the wicked.

    November 11, 2011 at 5:01 am | Reply
    • Greedy Banker


      Hillary is the worst example of a decent human being. She is an avoved zionists – she married her daughter into a zionist family – her husband is a zionist puppet . . . and worst of all, Hillary is a murderer.

      Please, CNN, blow yourself up!

      November 11, 2011 at 12:43 pm | Reply
    • Greedy Banker

      Please, CNN, blow yourself up!

      November 11, 2011 at 12:47 pm | Reply
      • aaron

        can she have one of your vest.

        November 12, 2011 at 12:48 pm |
  37. Chris C

    "socio-military-political-economic force with influence reaching deep into Iran's power structure" and having control of "strategic industries, commercial services, and black-market enterprises." If this is the definition of a military dictatorship, it would fit the United States's military industrial complex.

    November 10, 2011 at 6:55 pm | Reply
    • concerned

      Amen chris, you are absolutly right.

      No matter who you are and where you live, it all depends on what propaganda you're forced to listen to that shapes your oppinion.

      November 12, 2011 at 6:50 am | Reply
  38. reality

    Propaganda by Fascist people.

    November 10, 2011 at 12:29 pm | Reply
  39. John

    ""Those that are truly pious see the things that are taking place in Iran in the political realm are not reflective of their religious values," Sadjadpour says. "They see this widening income disparity between the haves and the have-nots, and many clerics don't respect Ayatollah Khamenei as a bona fide grand ayatollah.""

    not reflective of their religious values, eh?
    Well if you analyse the obscene population increases in Algeria,Egypt, tunisia,Lybia,Iran, you get it, Islam, and listen to the instructions of their imams and ayotollahs, you will reach the conclusion that the widening disparities in muslim countries are
    in direct proportion to the frequency of the widening of female muslim vaginas. Some attention needs to be paid to this phenomenon.

    November 10, 2011 at 10:43 am | Reply
  40. Arash Kamangeer

    Unfortunately, we lost our one very, very good chance in helping the Iranian protestors (Green Movement) gain legs and start an internal and organic change element. Even though The Green Movement was a subset of IRI, it has been, thus far, the best opportunity the world had in supporting to bring about a change in Iran. Souldawouldacoulda

    November 9, 2011 at 10:25 pm | Reply
    • astutemind

      We didn't have a chance in hell.

      November 10, 2011 at 12:29 am | Reply
      • Arash Kamangeer

        Surely, you jest? We had plenty of good opportunity. More news exposure, unfortunately in coincided with Micheal Jackson's death and we know how we love our pop icons, more help via VOA, more help by going direct to NOKIA, to this day I veer away from those ba$tards, and having them disable the tracking devices they sold to IRI, and more moral support by the western government. However, OIL outweighs all of this and no thanks to China and Russia either.

        November 10, 2011 at 7:42 pm |
    • Sean

      I had a high school classmate named Arash Kamangeer!!

      November 13, 2011 at 2:38 pm | Reply
  41. Persian

    Where is President Carter to see what he did 33 years ago, in the name of Human Rights? Shame on me.

    November 9, 2011 at 4:29 pm | Reply
    • TonyToniTone

      Jimmy's busy digging-up peanuts and still wonder why in the f ck he ever decided to give his human rights speech that day in Tehran.

      November 9, 2011 at 10:17 pm | Reply
  42. swpz

    Military dictatorship...? Perhaps but then again how much actual non biased research has been conducted from within Iran?

    Could say America is a military dictatorship; Patriot Act that strips constitutional rights, presidential "emergency powers" and "vetoes" make it a proverbial dictatorship.

    But it's debatable; police state however is not. Why not? Oh maybe because for example, the US police force is a force that rivals other modern armies in both manpower and weaponry?

    For a 'civilian' police force, I see no reason why they need all that equipment, it's not a war zone, who are they fighting?

    November 9, 2011 at 8:43 am | Reply
  43. Paul

    This sounds like a whole bunch of US propaganda. One could make the same argument about the US moving to a military dictatorship; with the implementation of the Patriot Act which dismisses constitutional rights, being able to prosecute a suspected terrorist with classified evidence that the judge nor the jury can see.

    Any attack on Iran will suffer consequences both in the Middle East, as well as around the world. Relations with China and Russia will grow sour, not forgetting to mention the economic repercussions. It is in the US's best interest to stay out of Middle Eastern Affairs, because the end result of an American intervention in the region has historically always been negative.

    November 8, 2011 at 11:19 pm | Reply
    • Judge Jury Executioner

      That's just great the Ostrich mentality stick your head in the sand (or someplace darker LOL) and do nothing? That will not do. What wait for them to park a MRV on your state airspace and deploy 8 warheads? I say pre emptive strike them as well as N. Korea.

      If the USA is to become the World Police then be done with it.

      November 10, 2011 at 10:24 am | Reply
  44. Mark Levy

    Not many western medias are talking about it, but since yesterday, according to the Russell Tribunal in South Africa: Israel=Apartheid.

    Do a search on google with " Russell Tribunal and Israel" and you will read interesting articles.

    Mark Levy, Jew for a Just peace

    November 8, 2011 at 12:20 pm | Reply
    • astutemind

      Well said Mark. You are one of the few True Jews remaining. I myself am Catholic/Christian but I don't consider Christians who support the dark arts of torture, and unnecessary war as true Christians. It's a pity our religions get hijacked by bloodthirsy warmongers.

      November 10, 2011 at 12:35 am | Reply
    • reality

      They only do propaganda for Zionazis.

      November 10, 2011 at 12:31 pm | Reply
  45. kerry

    While Arab Spring liberates other Muslim nations Iran moves backwards. Typical. Still, it is none of our business in the U.S., leave them to it. They wanted their revolution that put these people in power, they got it. No one to blame but themselves. Religion and politics don't mix. But the Muslims will never learn that lesson. Many will suffer and die because of it. No way around that.

    November 8, 2011 at 11:37 am | Reply
  46. ranger 830

    Ha ha the CIA IS KICKING YOUR ASSES AND YOU DONT EVEN REALIZE IT!!!!! IRAQ,AFGHANISTAN,LIBYA EGYPT,TUNESIA, WHO WILL BE NEXT TO FALL? Make no mistake we are winning one country at a time and you dont even realize it! Who will be next ?The middleast and asia are changing forever! The people are becoming wise to the lies of Islamist extreamists and fear mongers! With a little help the awakening has began !

    November 8, 2011 at 10:43 am | Reply
    • talus12

      Oh be quiet

      November 9, 2011 at 10:22 pm | Reply
    • reality

      You don't know if you are winning or losing it.

      November 10, 2011 at 12:33 pm | Reply
  47. ranger 830

    I would like to give the CIA. a huge round of applause! They are doing a fantastic job of stirring the pot and turning these muslims on each other! Islam will crumble from within! Iraq,Tunesia,Egypt,Afghanistan,libya etc. etc. These goat herders are to dim to see whats happening to them! Soon the attention will be turned to Iran and syria, you are next on the cia's hit list! When we leave Afghanistan and Iraq there will be cival war! They will be to busy killing eachother to perpetrate acts of terror! Egypt done , Libya done ,Tunesia done, whos next! If I were Iran I would be scared! Make no mistake we are winning this war one country at a time! The middle east and Asia will be left in such a shambles it will take years for you to recover from the beating handed to you by the agency! The worst thing is you dont even see it!

    November 8, 2011 at 10:36 am | Reply
  48. billybob22

    That chief mullah guy, Amentoallthat, well he is really a piece of work. Did you know that he was born in Tel Aviv? Well he was and Oy Vey to you if you did not know that. Next time you have a bridge party in the desert you can use this information to win. It will probably be the last time,because here in the US we are coming to eliminate y'all. Pass me the garlic bread, Fatima.

    November 8, 2011 at 6:20 am | Reply
    • Scrilla Villa

      You know, there are Arabs that live in Israel. And theyre not Jewish.

      November 11, 2011 at 11:18 am | Reply
      • billybob22

        Well now you know there are Iranians there too.

        December 1, 2011 at 12:30 am |
  49. billybob22

    The Iranian navy is a formidable weapon and we should all be wary that such a mighty force is at our doorstep. If they would only enlist Sanctum Sanctorum as their supreme Mullah, they would begin a tour of world domination that would be unmatched in the history of the Muslim culture,

    November 8, 2011 at 1:12 am | Reply
  50. General Patton

    We are the Iranians worst nightmare. This one is for Jimmy Carter. Jimmy, we are going to create a hell hole the likes unseen since Gengis Khan. Our plans are laid. Obama has authorized it. Hell is coming to Iran. You hear us Abu-sh|t-a-jad ? You and Your people are going down. Your men, women and children are going to be dead cold as the blood flows. We will give Israel the opening volley and then SHOCK !!! AWE !!! and HELL !!! are coming Your way !!! I say Frappay all the Muslim F*CKS !

    November 8, 2011 at 12:13 am | Reply
    • Jesse

      So General, our plans are laid & approved by the president, I'm sure right in front you. Let's see 12:10AM you can't sleep because you couldn't get it up in bed, got embaressed, walked out the bedroom, you're angry & viagra ain't working no more. Of course you've been sexually confused all your life. Let's face the fact, accept that you're gay & stop being angry.

      November 8, 2011 at 10:48 am | Reply
      • Boltzz

        Jesse... Do u have nothing better to do than to leave ur negative 2 cents under everyone elses comments?? You better log off.. the sand n!gger wants his play thang

        November 9, 2011 at 11:34 am |
    • art

      love it hope all middle east disappears.

      November 8, 2011 at 2:33 pm | Reply
    • TonyToniTone

      I remember reading that Patton did have pederast tendencies. What's he doing up and running around. Hey, idiot, don't EVER use Patton's name for this kind of s h i t postings.

      November 9, 2011 at 10:22 pm | Reply
  51. pistoya

    We are going into Iran soon Thank God. It is a fight for our faith. Just remember Our God is an awsome God, He reigns from heaven above and when he gives us the word to go in, we will paint the Iranian sands with their blood. This not just some mild show of force. Our military planners have done a superb job. We will clean out their clocks. They will be messing their pants as we rain down hell out of the sky.

    November 7, 2011 at 11:56 pm | Reply
    • Jesse

      Yeh Pistoya, isn't it great. Your husband should get deployed any day now. Just think that I'll be overy day & we'll have wild sex multiple times. Thank god for these wars!

      November 8, 2011 at 10:37 am | Reply


      November 8, 2011 at 12:06 pm | Reply
      • Bass

        Did anyone else ncotie how weird the dragon in this video was. It moved very strangely and it had no ropes must of been the touring production. Right? Am I right? Please don't ignore me. Please?

        May 22, 2012 at 12:49 pm |
  52. Halliburton

    We accept NO Concessions. Iran must subjugate to US control or we will go in and blow these people sky high complete with carbon burnt corpses just like we did in Libya. Our men and women in uniform are completely up to the challenge. We've got battallions of patriotic soldiers ready to go in and kill them all. They go ready to lay down their lives and die if necessary so that we can ensure freedom and peace for the us, our allies and rest of the world.

    November 7, 2011 at 6:05 pm | Reply
    • Jesse

      Come on halliburton, you can accept some concession, just a little????
      our boys & girls in uniform are up to it, but you're not up to it punk are you???? You're not even in a uniform, are you?
      You're probably homeless guy sitting in a librarby in Tuskaluka Alabama having fun boy, am i right punk?
      Our patriotic boys are ready to go kill em all but not you, cause you're too stoned?
      Or are you too drunk punk? Why don't you go find a bridge, lay down under & take a nap! the low's gonna hit you soon!
      You're so brave, you're a real rambo.

      November 7, 2011 at 11:19 pm | Reply
    • astutemind

      "Ensure freedom"??? LOL. We haven't fought any war for freedom since WWII. That jedi mind trick has been exhausted. I think you need something new to rally the gullible.

      November 10, 2011 at 12:51 am | Reply
  53. War Hawk

    There is no alternative. We must bomb the F()CK out of these bastards ! WAR IS THE ONLY ANSWER ! We must get our boots on the ground to secure the perimeter and turn these F()CKERS into an INFERNO !!! OBAMA WAKE THE HELL UP !!!!!

    November 7, 2011 at 6:01 pm | Reply
    • Jesse

      War Hawk,
      I'd say you're a typical American. All Talk, no Balls!
      We've been thretening these people for over 30 yrs.
      in the interim we went to war with Somalia, Iraq, afghanistan, Sudan, Serbia, Libya, Panama, god knows where else!
      But we never went to war with Iran? We didn't even try, did we? Are we afraid of them?
      you're a typical hawk, all talks no balls. We go to war with tiny countries, we lose those wars too.
      Typical american Hawk, all talks, no balls. Just like you, a big MOUTH!!!!!!
      I bet you're one of those that if get caught in a real fight, with a real man, you'll poop all over yourself, hey?
      Go do your homework, & go to bed kid. You gotta go to school tomorrow. GO ON KID GO ON I SAID!

      November 7, 2011 at 11:09 pm | Reply
      • art

        hey jessie you sound like your all talk and no action why dont you get your punk ass up and enlist SCARRY PIECE OF SHIT!!

        November 8, 2011 at 2:38 pm |
      • astutemind

        Oh poor Art, no imagination...just parroting what Jesse said using the old "I'm rubber you're glue" schtick.

        November 10, 2011 at 12:38 am |
      • Ground Zero

        We are not supposed to "win" wars.
        When you win, the war is over.
        Those in charge of the military industrial complex
        dont get richer when peace breakes out.

        November 10, 2011 at 12:58 pm |
      • Scrilla Villa

        Jesse – You seem like you really disliked that post.

        November 11, 2011 at 11:22 am |
  54. hass

    In 2003, Iran offered to make complete peace with the US and even to recognize Israel. This and many other Iranian concessions have been ignored, because Iranian 'nuclear weapons' are just an excuse for forcing regime change in Iran, just as "WMDs in IRaq" was just an excuse for a war.

    November 7, 2011 at 12:19 pm | Reply
    • C.Brown

      That article was a load of BS PERIOD! WMD in Iraq and the situation in Iran are very different. Did you read the IAEA report released today? WMD in Iraq was a very real thing at one time (just ask anyone that was in country during the first war) and the U.S. acted on false information that even other countries stupidly believed which came from a North Africa so explain how the situation in Iraq is the same as Iran seeing as how their is proof that Iran is enriching uranium. The IAEA dosen't work for the U.S. and has filed independant reports on this matter how about you read those statements and leave out these weird and hard to verify blogs your reading that seem to included a lot of speculation.

      November 7, 2011 at 3:53 pm | Reply
      • astutemind

        When you mention speculation I presume you are referring to the IAEA report, because it doesn't actually accuse Iran of building a bomb. If it were to do so that would be a categorical lie since ALL of Iran's uranium stock are accounted for and none diverted from civilian/peaceful use to military use, so by definition they are not making a bomb in the same way accusing someone of making apple pie without the apples by definition means they're not making apple pie.

        Therefore the report is nothing more than a document subject to speculation – nothing more. And we know by definition they could not be making a bomb. And by the way Iraq and Iran are similar in that LIES were told to support military action like aluminum tubes for centrifuges and nuclear programs even after US inspectors like Scott Ritter confirmed no such programs or weapons existed. By the way the IAEA doesn't officially work for the US but the head of that agency is a US puppet. Same difference.

        November 10, 2011 at 12:47 am |
    • Greg Amar

      Unfortunately, not true, or else the US and EU would have jumped at it. Most muslim dominated regimes cannot survive without the threat of "Zionism" or some other rally crime to take the attention from local persecution.

      November 7, 2011 at 5:37 pm | Reply
      • hass

        Sorry, perfectly true

        November 8, 2011 at 10:22 am |
  55. Migo

    I thought it was ALREADY a military dictatorship..........oh, wait....its a pseudo "religious" dictatorship, or maybe just a "standard" dictatorship and now it's just adding MORE guns for enforcement.

    Wonder why freedom, free will, and or freedom of choice is such a scary idea for these benighted fools............

    November 7, 2011 at 11:09 am | Reply
    • Jesse

      yeh migo, you're a brilliant mind!
      just crossed the border didn't you?
      No border patrols again?

      November 7, 2011 at 11:23 pm | Reply
      • art


        November 8, 2011 at 2:40 pm |
      • astutemind

        Hey Art! Lose the "I'm rubber you're glue" schtick. You sound like a pimple.

        November 10, 2011 at 12:48 am |
  56. GI Joe

    Clearly, it is time to launch an all out air campaign complete with bunker busters and nukes. Kill them all and make Iran a stifle of volcanic glass. We need to do this right now. Politicians wake up !!!!!!! Now is the time !

    November 7, 2011 at 9:44 am | Reply
    • Mark Levy

      yeah GI Joe, maybe you are the one who should be killed for saying such stupid words...

      November 7, 2011 at 5:34 pm | Reply
    • Jesse

      & where will you be GI joe?
      sitting on bowl trying to pass the squirrel ????
      Yeh....politician wake up, Gi Joe is constipated! Can't pass the squirrel. he's angry he wants war & destruction.
      Take deeeep breeeeaaathhhs boy, let it let it out ..... tat-a-boy.

      November 7, 2011 at 11:31 pm | Reply

Leave a Reply to Greg Amar


CNN welcomes a lively and courteous discussion as long as you follow the Rules of Conduct set forth in our Terms of Service. Comments are not pre-screened before they post. You agree that anything you post may be used, along with your name and profile picture, in accordance with our Privacy Policy and the license you have granted pursuant to our Terms of Service.