Turkish prime minister to visit Egypt as regional tension widens
Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan is embarking on a three nation tour. Photo: AFP/Getty Images
September 12th, 2011
11:55 AM ET

Turkish prime minister to visit Egypt as regional tension widens

By CNN's Ivan Watson

Turkey's prime minister is poised to visit Egypt, as twin diplomatic crises are shaking the foundations of several critical Middle Eastern alliances.

Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan arrives here Monday night, part of a three nation tour that will include Tunisia and Libya as Turkey expands its diplomatic efforts.

Israeli ambassadors have been forced to abandon their posts in both Turkey and Egypt over the past week, albeit for sharply different reasons.

On Friday, Israel's ambassador to Egypt fled the country along with other Israeli diplomats, after an angry crowd broke down a protective wall around the Israeli Embassy in Cairo and stormed the bottom floor of the diplomatic mission.

Egypt's ruling military council denounced the riot and announced the re-activation a controversial series of emergency laws to restore order. It also vowed to honor the peace treaty it signed with its Israeli neighbor in the historic 1979 Camp David accords.

Meanwhile, Turkey, which was once Israel's closest friend in the Muslim world, ejected Israel's ambassador and other top diplomats earlier this month and suspended all bilateral military agreements.

Ankara is furious that Israel has not apologized for the May 2010 killing of eight Turkish citizens and a Turkish-American humanitarian worker aboard an aid convoy headed to Gaza. Israeli commandos raided the vessel to prevent it from breaking Israel's sea blockade of the Palestinian territory.

Analysts say Turkey's diplomatic offensive against Israel struck a chord in Egyptian society.

Last month, Israeli troops opened fire on Egyptian border guards after unknown attackers carried out a deadly attack that killed eight Israelis on the Israeli side of the frontier.

A sixth Egyptian soldier died of wounds received during that incident last weekend. Israel has expressed regret and launched an investigation into the attack. But the Jewish state has not offered a formal apology or any compensation to the families of the victims.

"Definitely the Egyptians started to make a comparison between what Turkey did and what the Egyptian government did. And at the end of the day they want action," said Sameh Seif Elyazal, a retired Egyptian army general and Cairo-based political analyst. "No action at all has been put in place by the Egyptian government."

During Friday night's clashes in Cairo, some protesters at the Israeli Embassy were seen carrying posters of Erdogan, the Turkish prime minister.

"I really like him because he is a firm man who kicked out the Israeli ambassador. We will welcome him here," said a driver named Naguib Ali one day after the riots. He was walking through the neighborhood of Giza, where Egyptian troops are now protecting the empty Israeli Embassy.

"He [Erdogan] has this big image in the region, which is new to Turkey," said Hugh Pope, an Istanbul-based analyst with the International Crisis Group. "Because of the success and legitimacy of the Erdogan government and his ability to merge both the Muslim side of Turkey's identity with secular, successful and commercially powerful government, it has made Turkey much more attractive."

Ottoman Turkey ruled much of the Arab world for centuries, until the empire collapsed after World War I.

The subsequent, staunchly secular Turkish republic long kept itself at a distance from its Arab neighbors, orienting itself instead towards Western countries and the NATO military alliance.

That changed when Erdogan's Justice and Development Party swept to power after winning elections in 2002.

Erdogan's government embarked on a "zero problems" foreign policy that sought to mend relations with eastern neighbors, while also opening markets to Turkish goods and services.

But since the Turkish prime minister won another resounding victory in last June's parliamentary elections, analysts say that spirit of cooperation has faded.

"There is no more 'zero problems,'" said Pope, of the International Crisis Group. "Turkey has generally assumed a more muscular approach, a more confrontational approach and the most obvious example of this is Israel."

Erdogan has repeatedly said he hopes to visit Gaza during his visit to Egypt, which many would interpret as a slap in the face of the Israeli government.

Egyptian authorities clearly want to avoid this scenario, say analysts in Cairo, because it would exacerbate existing tensions with Israel.

"Going to Gaza will embarrass Egypt a lot," explained retired army general Elyazal. "Because if he goes to Gaza he would have to pass through the Egyptian border."

Unlike Erdogan, who governs Turkey with a strong domestic mandate and a booming economy, the interim government in Egypt is struggling to cope with a deep economic crisis and growing anger on the streets.

Egyptian revolutionaries frustrated with the slow pace of reform since the overthrow of longtime strongman and Israeli ally Hosni Mubarak, have ramped up criticism of Egypt's ruling military.

Its not clear how comfortable Egypt's military commanders will be with Erdogan.

The Turkish politician has fought and won a long-running political war with his country's own military commanders. In the last three years, Turkish police have arrested more than 100 Turkish generals and admirals accused of plotting to overthrow his government.

"The purpose of the visit is to show our support to the Egyptian people in their struggle to establish a democratic socio-political order based on justice, freedom, transparency and rule of law," wrote Ibrahim Kalin, Erdogan's foreign policy adviser, in an e-mail to CNN. "The same values which Turkey has been implementing in its domestic and foreign policy."

One Egyptian political movement that appears ready to welcome the Turks with open arms is the Muslim Brotherhood, which was long persecuted by ousted president Mubarak.

"It is good for him to come here, as he is one of the most eminent leaders in the region," said Dr. Essam Elerian, a spokesman and top official in the Brotherhood. "There is vacuum now in the region. And Turkey is playing an important role."

Journalist Mohamed Fadel Fahmy contributed to this report

Post by:
Filed under: Diplomacy • Egypt
soundoff (5 Responses)
  1. Leonarda Calles

    I am baffled by the data in this blog I found it to be not only incredibly interesting but it really also made me think. It is hard now a days to find relevant information to ones search, so I am happy that I found this article post

    http://is.gd/AAxnjH Egyptian Astronomy

    November 9, 2014 at 5:03 pm | Reply
  2. istanbul tours

    I went to Turkey for 2 nights and 3 days and ı made an arrangement with this company for a package tour and ı spent a good time in Istanbul. We visited the beauty places of this marvelous city. First day we went on a dinner cruise on Bosphorus and ı had a lot of fun with so many kinds of dance shows and good dinner too. I loved the mezzes. Second day we went on a tour and visited the Sultanahmet aria http://www.privatetoursinistanbul.com Every corner looks like a part of history. Hagia Sophia and Chora Church are very beautiful museums. The mosaics of these basilicas are very good protected. I was fascinated. I badly recommend you to go on a cruise on Bosphorus at night. Istanbul looks very different at night is shining. I had a very enjoyable Dinner cruise on Bosphorus accompanied by Turkish Shows. I will definitely visit again Turkey. Thank you for your services.

    September 25, 2011 at 9:03 am | Reply
  3. KakaJ

    Some of us had all along warned of this, and predicted it to happen. The world is yet to see more terrifying things – especially after the RADICALS cum EXTREMISTS (alkhaidha) take over political and military control in the Middle East and the Arab world. Following the reported systematic looting of a Soviet form of STINGER missiles from Libya's armories, the world is about to witness an extended 'NO FLY ZONE'. I wonder whether NATO, USA, and allies did think through the consequences when they decided to invade Libya and force out Col Gadaffi. I can say it again that the world will be worse off without Gaddafi than with him in Libya. I am not an apologist for Gadaffi, but the fellows taking over control in Libya and the Middle East including Yemen, are A VERY BIG THREAT TO INTERNATIONAL PEACE & SECURITY. Oil and gas should never have blinded us to this extent!! The future will absolve me!!

    September 13, 2011 at 7:38 am | Reply
  4. axel

    how come it is not mentioned in the article that turkey is threatening an american company (nobel) which has an agreement with cyprus (eu) to drill in their eez for gas; that turkey is also threatening cyprus for such drilling and that turkey is illegaly occupying part of cyprus since 1974. the u.n., eu and usa all have told turkey to back off and turkey has sent warships as a threat. ???

    September 12, 2011 at 2:23 pm | Reply
  5. alamin

    It is a sign showing that for once somebody out there is not sleeping @isreal's draconian seige on gaza

    September 12, 2011 at 1:18 pm | Reply

Leave a Reply to alamin


CNN welcomes a lively and courteous discussion as long as you follow the Rules of Conduct set forth in our Terms of Service. Comments are not pre-screened before they post. You agree that anything you post may be used, along with your name and profile picture, in accordance with our Privacy Policy and the license you have granted pursuant to our Terms of Service.