Investigations shed new light on Toulouse terrorist shootings
June 13th, 2012
12:05 AM ET

Investigations shed new light on Toulouse terrorist shootings

By Paul Cruickshank

It was shooting spree that terrorized France for 10 days, and for weeks dominated the country's presidential election campaign.

Starting on March 11, Mohammed Merah, a 23 year old French-Algerian motor-bike riding assassin, who kept the visor on his helmet shut as he killed, and filmed every detail in high definition from a camera on his torso, shot four French paratroopers in two attacks, killing three and paralyzing one, and then on March 19 shot at point blank range three children and their teacher at a Jewish school in Toulouse, in an attack that shocked the world.

In an unprecedented manhunt, police tracked the killer to his apartment in Toulouse, where he held out during a two-day siege.During a seven-hour rambling confession to negotiators, he claimed to be acting on behalf of al Qaeda. He was killed in a blaze of gunfire as security services stormed the building on March 22.

Hours later Jund al Khilafah, known as JaK, an obscure Kazakh Jihadist group with ties to al Qaeda whose leaders are thought to be based in the tribal areas of Pakistan, claimed responsibility for the attacks.

"We claim our responsibility for these blessed operations," the group claimed, referring to the shooter as Yusuf al Firansi (the French) in an Arabic communiqué translated by the SITE Intelligence Group.

Counterterrorism officials initially treated the claim skeptically because the group had no track record of international terrorist operations.

But a senior U.S. counterterrorism official told CNN that Merah is now believed to have linked up with the Kazakh group just months before the attacks .

The U.S. official said there was "strong intelligence" that Merah spent time with the group in the tribal areas of Pakistan during a trip he made there between August and October 2011. "We're talking about a short time, perhaps even only an afternoon," said the official, who added that this did not necessarily mean the Kazakh group directed Merah to launch the shootings in France.

In the weeks after Merah's death there was much debate over whether he was an example of a "lone-wolf terrorist," plotting and acting alone, or had been recruited into the al Qaeda terrorist network, as he claimed to negotiators during the siege.

The reality, according to the senior U.S. official and a new book "The Merah Affair: the Investigation" set to be published in France next week, appears to be somewhere in-between.

French journalists Éric Pelletier and Jean-Marie Pontaut, who provided an advance copy of their book to CNN, reveal that Merah told negotiators during the siege that his handlers in Pakistan tasked him with assassinating an Indian diplomat in Paris. Merah claimed that on his return to France he rejected this mission, and instead decided to assassinate French soldiers to retaliate against the French military presence in Afghanistan. He claimed that on March 19 he only decided to attack the Jewish school in Toulouse after he discovered that the soldier he was targeting that day was not at home.

No evidence has emerged that Merah was in touch with jihadists in Pakistan after he returned to France in October 2011. He appears to have planned the attacks himself. French authorities have so far alleged the only other co-conspirator was his older brother, Abdelkader Merah, a radical fundamentalist long on their radar screen, who they arrested after Merah's death and charged with assisting in the plot. Abdelkader denies the charges, but according to the authors told French investigators he was proud of the way his brother died as a fighter.

The book outlines several reasons why French authorities began to take the claim by JaK, the Kazakh group, seriously. One was that Abdelkader Merah told investigators his brother liked to be called Yusuf - the name JaK called him – by close family members, and this was only known inside the family. Another was they established that Merah had opened an Internet account under that name.

Furthermore, in a second statement of responsibility on March 31 a JaK operative revealed several pieces of information about Merah not then in the public domain, such as a trip he made to the Kurdish areas of northern Iraq, which were subsequently verified by French authorities, according to the book.

"The French think the claim is genuine: They don't have any doubt anymore," Pelletier said.

When Merah spent two weeks in the Miranshah area in North Waziristan in September 2011, a "major Western intelligence agency" had Merah on their radar screen, according to the authors. Electronic eavesdropping detected the opening of two Internet addresses in Miranshah that September, according to the authors, but Pelletier said it remained unclear at what point the agency established the account belonged to Merah.

It was only after the killings that French domestic security services were told that Merah spent time in North Waziristan during this period, according to the authors, raising the possibility that crucial intelligence that might have prevented the attack was not shared in time. When Merah returned to France from Pakistan in the fall of 2011, he was interrogated by domestic security agents who wanted to know the reason for his travel, but after he claimed his Pakistan trip was for tourism, he was judged as no immediate threat. Pelletier said it was not clear when France's foreign intelligence service was informed about his travel to North Waziristan.

After the killings, the Western intelligence agency informed French domestic security services that a number used by Merah in North Waziristan had also been used to contact terrorists belonging to Harakat al Mujahideen, a Kashmiri group with close links to al Qaeda, according to the authors, raising the possibility Merah was in touch with the group.

One of Harakat al Mujahideen's top commanders was Ilyas Kashmiri, a veteran Pakistani jihadist who in the two years before his reported death in a drone strike in June 2011 simultaneously played a lead role in orchestrating al Qaeda plots against the West, including a "Mumbai-Style" plot against Europe that led to an unprecedented U.S. State Department travel advisory for the Continent in October 2010, according to intelligence officials.

Pelletier said that this possible link to Harakat al Mujahideen may explain orders Merah apparently received to assassinate an Indian diplomat in Paris.

After the killings, French domestic security services learned that Merah received two days of "ultra-rapid" training in North Waziristan, according to the authors, after being vetted because of concerns he might be a spy.

JaK claimed it provided Merah with this instruction, after he reached their encampments.

"In Islamabad he came to know some people who took him to the Taliban and who, on their part, facilitated his arrival to the tribal areas, where he eventually ended up joining our brigade," one of the group's operatives calling himself Abu al-Qa'qa' al-Andalusi claimed in the March 31 statement in Arabic translated by the SITE Intelligence Group. Pelletier and Pontier wrote that subsequent investigations had confirmed Merah's passage through Pakistan's capital.

The JaK operative in the same statement described the nature of the training Merah received. "He did not desire to train in explosives, even though that was available to him within a very narrow circle of no more than three individuals. He preferred fighting with weapons, as he told me ... assassinations were more appropriate for him." The operative claimed the two of them conversed in French.

Al-Andalusi wrote that Merah nevertheless agreed to launch a suicide bombing attack in the Afghanistan-Pakistan border region but "one day after the program was changed for reasons that cannot be explained, Yusuf started his return to France, promising to accomplish what he is capable."

"Martyrdom was his goal and the hope that was always on his mind," he said.

JaK is believed responsible for several attacks against security forces in Kazakhstan, including the country's first suicide bombing and gun and grenade attacks, since its founding in September 2011, and has increasingly embraced al Qaeda's ideology of global jihad, Jacob Zenn, a Jamestown Foundation analyst who has researched the group said earlier this year.

Zenn said it is possible that a crackdown by security services in Kazakhstan has driven more of its members to the relative safe haven of the Afghanistan-Pakistan border region, where he said a few dozen of the group's members may have integrated with other jihadists.

Eyewitness accounts by European militants who traveled to the tribal areas of Pakistan suggest that lines have blurred between al Qaeda and other jihadist groups operating in the area.

Path to jihad

"The Merah Affair" sheds significant new light on Merah's radicalization, by drawing on interviews with family members, close associates and files kept on him by French security services.

The book paints a picture of a troubled truant from a broken home, who was impossible for his mother to control. For a time he was transferred to the care of social services. He spent hours playing "shoot-em-up" video games, and his adolescence increasingly turned to petty crime.

His father returned to Algeria when he was very young and his key influence became his older brother Abdelkader, a domineering Salafist fundamentalist who also had a history of petty crime, according to the authors.

After being imprisoned in January 2008 for a knife assault, Merah was born again into Islam through contact with other Muslim prisoners, according to fellow inmates. One of them claimed Abdelkader Merah played a central role in his radicalization in prison by supplying him with recordings of jihadist chanting, which Abdelkader Merah's lawyer denies, according to the authors. The book reveals that Merah found prison life difficult and once attempted suicide.

Abdelghani Merah, one of Merah's older brothers, told investigators that his brother had become radicalized by the time he was released from prison in September 2009, and began to express his rage over the presence of French troops in Afghanistan, the book reveals. His mother told investigators that for a period he hung out with radicals in the Toulouse area.

Mohammed and Abdelkader Merah had first came on the radar screen of French counterterrorism officials in the mid-2000s because both were loosely connected to a group of extremists in the Toulouse area that was recruiting militants to fight in Iraq, according to the authors. In 2011, Abdelkader Merah even arranged a short-lived marriage between his mother and the father of Sabri Essid, one of the convicted facilitators, who was sentenced to a short time in prison in France after being detained in Syria in 2006.

Abdelghani Merah, the other brother, who had become estranged from Abdelkader Merah after the latter sharply disapproved of his marriage to a Jewish woman, told investigators that Mohammed Merah was a subservient side-kick to Abdelkader Merah when they were growing up, according to the authors. "Abdelkader rottened the life of Mohammed," Abddelghani Merah said. "It was him, I'm certain that gave the idea to Mohammed."

Mohammed Merah's radical activity was escalating. In June 2010 Merah forced a 15-year-old boy to watch violent jihadist propaganda, including the execution of American hostages, according to a complaint made to the police at the time by the youth's mother, according to the book. After he learned she had filed a police report, he threatened her and punched her son, according to her account. She told a French newspaper that he told her he was a Muhajid and would die a martyr.

During the siege, Merah claimed he had been trying to participate in jihad for several years. In early summer 2010, he tried to enlist in the French Foreign Legion, but was rejected. According to Pelletier and Pontier, he told negotiators his plan had been to turn his guns on his fellow soldiers once in Afghanistan, and join the Taliban insurgency. Between July and October 2010 he traveled to several Middle Eastern countries, including Syria, Iraq, the Palestinian territories, Israel and Egypt, where Abdelkader Merah was spending some time pursuing religious studies. His brother later told investigators that Merah confided details of his trip to him during his stay. He envisaged at that time fighting jihad in Somalia or Sudan, according to the authors.

"I now realize that he was searching a for a way to get the contacts he needed to join al Qaeda and meet an emir who could decide what he should do. To commit the acts which he did, you have to get the sanction of a sheikh or emir," Abdelkader Merah later told investigators, according to the authors.

After briefly returning to Toulouse, Merah set off for Afghanistan via Tajikistan. His plan, he later said during the siege, was to get himself kidnapped by the Taliban and then persuade them he shared their views so he could join their ranks, the book revealed. The plan failed: Merah was apprehended in Kandahar in November 2010 by Afghan police before he could connect with militants, and briefly transferred to American custody. But Merah had entered Afghanistan lawfully and there were no grounds to detain him, so he was allowed to return to France.

Increasingly on the radar screen

It was only when he was back in France in January 2011 that he answered the police summons in relation to the altercation with the French youth the previous summer. He told police he was not an extremist, and the complaint was false, according to the authors. After the plaintiffs indicated they did not want to see him do prison time, police told him he was free to go.

But his trip to Afghanistan had placed him more firmly on the radar of French domestic security services. They wiretapped his phones, but after finding no incriminating evidence, ceased listening to his phone conversations in April 2011 as they were legally required to do, according to the authors.

The security services continued their human surveillance of him, logging 1,200 hours by August 2011 and installing a surveillance camera in front of his apartment building, according the authors. But Merah showed no signs of radicalism, nor did he have any contact with extremists in the Toulouse area.

His life did not seem out of the ordinary. To support himself he was working as a mechanic in various vehicle repair shops as well as receiving French welfare payments, according to the authors.

He managed to slip away to Pakistan in August without French security services noticing.

When security services learned that month that he had disappeared, French domestic security officials contacted his mother, who told them he had left for Pakistan in search of a wife, according to the book. The security services told her to tell him they wanted to see him on his return to France.

Merah soon called them back from Pakistan, promising he would get in touch with them as soon as he returned to France. He was true to his word. After a brief spell in hospital because he had contracted hepatitis A during his travels, he met with them and allayed their concerns, according to the book.

In the months that followed he did not seem like a man on a mission. In December 2011 he married a 17-year-old French Muslim who wore the full veil, but they quickly divorced, according to one of his fellow mechanics, because she did not take care of the housework, the book revealed.

Several months later, Merah carried out the shootings. According to the authors, he tracked down the first paratrooper he shot by searching for the terms "soldier" and "motorbike" online on his mother's computer, which took him to an online ad posted by a French paratrooper selling his motorbike. After the two arranged to meet, he shot the paratrooper, making sure he was dead with a final shot at point blank range.

In a brilliant piece of lateral thinking, it was by exhaustively cataloging who in France had searched these Internet search terms that French police were led to Merah, according to Pelletier and Pontier. CCTV footage at the scene of the second paratrooper shooting had also revealed which type of motorbike the assassin was driving, and the police became almost certain Merah was responsible when investigations established Merah was driving this type of model, the book revealed.

After his death, police found a thumb drive in Merah's trouser pocket with a file named "Al Qaeda Attacks France" which contained video of his shootings set to jihadist music. He had already sent a copy to al Jazeera offices in Paris. The network decided not to air it.

soundoff (84 Responses)
  1. smewaybeebmah

    Irak vet at gulvet av martyrene , plasket en natt med regn, jeg vet ikke uskarpe øyne utskrifter.

    http://www.antonettes.dk/tilbehors.html,

    Billige Nike Free Run 2,

    http://www.automationlab.dk/dk/hrd.asp,

    http://www.brockhoffsarkiv.dk/lmx.asp,

    canada goose jakke dame tilbud,

    November 25, 2013 at 5:59 am | Reply
  2. gliese 42

    More Merah's are residing in France as they finally say victory to Charles Martelll

    June 13, 2012 at 10:12 pm | Reply
  3. Joe L

    "He was killed in a blaze of gunfire..." The expression, Mr. Cruickshank, is 'blaze of glory,' and it certainly doesn't apply to the murderous Islamic pig Mohammed Merah was, even to describe his well-deserved death.

    June 13, 2012 at 5:53 pm | Reply
  4. Ed

    This Islamic person trained in Pakistan. Then he shot many innocent people. He enjoyed making a video recording of his victims while they died. And he wanted the Islamic TV al Jazeera to show this video to his fellow muslims to enjoy. Merah is certainly sub-human. I am sure his Allah must love him even more now for being such a devout muslim.

    June 13, 2012 at 2:17 pm | Reply
  5. David

    Merah's family is suing the government of France. Can you believe that? Muslims!!

    June 13, 2012 at 1:44 pm | Reply
  6. When the Cows Come Home

    NEW YORK: Renowned Indian activist and novelist Arundhati Roy has decried the silence of the international community over the continued “brutal Indian occupation of Kashmir” and said Kashmiris should be given the right to self-determination.
    “Kashmir is one of the most protracted and bloody occupations in the world — and one of the most ignored,” she told a large audience at the Asia Society during a discussion on “Kashmir — a case for freedom”.
    Under the Indian military rule in Kashmir, Ms Roy said, freedom of speech was non-existent and human rights abuses were routine. Elections were rigged and the press controlled.
    She said the lives of Kashmiris were made miserable by gun-totting security personnel who harassed and terrorised people with impunity, adding that disappearances were almost a daily occurrence as also kidnapping, arrests, fake encounters and torture. Mass graves have been discovered and the conscience of the world remains unstirred……
    The apathy towards Kashmir, especially in the western world, Ms Roy said, was because of their pursuit of commercial interests in India where they were more eager to “sell their goods than human rights”……..

    June 13, 2012 at 1:32 pm | Reply
  7. Aaron Chaney

    Romney vs. Frankenstein (Obama)

    Put simply, better the devil you don't know. Vote Romney.

    June 13, 2012 at 12:21 pm | Reply
  8. Sam

    France showed true leadership in several major areas: (1) showed the world the modern form of democracy, and (2) banned oppressive costumes for muslim women, (3) France also showed true grit when they squashed Merah. Now it is time for France to demonstrate true leadership again by showing the world how to take care of the muslim immigration problem in civilized countries.

    June 13, 2012 at 11:02 am | Reply
  9. Michelle

    The article makes me think, what is the best way to nip these fringe add-on killlers, in the bud? Sounds like prison is a veritable breeding ground for warping someones mind, well of course all prisoners in prison are master manipulators, and a newcomer has stress trauma going on, and his brain will be easier manipulated. Prisons already try to quash gang activity, its illegal in prison, but it appears the current methods are not working. Aside from that, take out the religious nut aspect, and how else do authorities deal with large gangs? MS113 seems to have been slowed a bit. The gangs are running crazy in Mexico so thats no good example. Im surprised we have not started addressing that cuz they will move north, its all about profit. Authorities in the countries of residence should have gang units like LA, and arrest all the time for legit crimes, and keep pulling them off the street. Yes they get replaced, but then the power is shifted so that its them as little criminals trying to get away from the powerful police, instead of big bad terrorist. But i blah blah real good.

    June 13, 2012 at 7:57 am | Reply
    • Rational Libertarian

      Obviously this doesn't apply to terrorists, but legalizing drugs would absolutely devastate gang activity, especially in Mexico. Also, drub prohibition is unconst.itutional anyway. However, those Democrat/Republican retards won't do anything about it.

      June 13, 2012 at 8:07 am | Reply
      • Rational Libertarian

        What crimes have his family and friends been convicted of?

        Also, Gitmo doesn't work either. Anybody convicted of terrorist activity should be executed.

        June 13, 2012 at 8:58 am |
      • Harry

        Please read the article: "older brother, Abdelkader Merah, a radical fundamentalist long on their radar screen, who they arrested after Merah's death and charged with assisting in the plot".
        Merah's friends and family should be placed in Gitmo.
        Gitmo really works!! That is why Obama did not shut it down. Bipartisan agreement is so hard to find these days; however, there is a bipartisan support for Gitmo due to its effectiveness against muslim terrorists.

        June 13, 2012 at 10:02 am |
    • Harry

      You are so right. Regular prisons will not be effective for muslims. Muslims need gitmo. France needs its own Gitmo where they need to send Merah's family and friends.

      June 13, 2012 at 8:55 am | Reply
  10. krm1007 ©™

    ATTACKS ON CHRISTIANS BY HINDUS IN INDIA:::::

    The Sri Ram Sene was one of the most active groups that launched a series of attacks on Christians and their property in and around Mangalore city in the southern state of Karnataka, India in August-September 2008, according to a report, “The Ugly Face of Sangh Parivar,” published by the People’s Union of Civil Liberties (PUCL), in March 2009. In Jabalpur city in the central state of Madhya Pradesh, suspected extremists from the Abhinav Bharat attacked the Rhema Gospel Church on Sept. 28, according to the Global Council of Indian Christians. They had earlier attacked Pastor Sam Oommen and his family in the same city on Aug. 3.

    June 13, 2012 at 7:10 am | Reply
  11. krm1007 ©™

    New, More Dangerous Hindu Extremist Groups Emerge in India

    Christians concerned as rightwing factions splinter to form militant outfits.
    PUNE, India, October 29 (CDN) — After more than a decade of severe persecution, India’s Christian minority is growing increasingly concerned over the mushrooming of newer and deadlier Hindu extremist groups.

    Gone are the days when Christians had to watch out only for the Vishwa Hindu Parishad (World Hindu Council) and its youth wing, Bajrang Dal, which are closely linked with the most influential Hindu extremist umbrella organization, the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS). With voter support faltering for the RSS’s political wing, the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), moderate and extremist sections within the Hindu nationalist movement are blaming each other, and militant splinter groups have emerged.

    Claiming to be breakaway factions of the RSS, new groups with even more extreme ideology are surfacing. The Abhinav Bharat (Pride of India), the Rashtriya Jagran Manch (National Revival Forum), the Sri Ram Sene (Army of god Rama), the Hindu Dharam Sena (Army for Hindu Religion) and the Sanatan Sanstha (Eternal Organization) have launched numerous violent attacks on Christian and Muslim minorities.

    June 13, 2012 at 7:08 am | Reply
  12. Greg

    Merah's handlers were Pakistanis who trained him and asked him to carry out acts terrorism in France. Pakistan harbors these terrorist handlers. NATO and France should consider it an act of war by Pakistan against them. Pakistan should be given a deadline to hand over the handlers of Merah. Or they need to face the consequences for their state sponsored terrorism.

    June 13, 2012 at 7:00 am | Reply
    • Rational Libertarian

      Do you have any proof that the upper echelons of the Pakistani government are harboring terrorists?

      June 13, 2012 at 7:15 am | Reply
  13. Hakeem

    It is sickening and its only a sick and twisted person that will regard killing of innocent people a well done mission. We need to have proactive laws that can help remove these set of people from society before they cause harm to other people. We must be firm in our resolve to fight terrorism anywhere it may exist in the world

    June 13, 2012 at 5:46 am | Reply
    • Byron

      Merah was not a lone wolf. Merah was trained by Pakistan. That is what the new book is all about.

      June 13, 2012 at 8:57 am | Reply
  14. paulmartinforeigncoresspondent

    JIhadists seem to share common factors...they hate their lives, usually welfare recipients,etc and are intellectually weak so easily led into precarious insanity to murder folk they have NEVER met and who have done them NO harm !

    Those who can make people believe in absurdities....can also make them commit atrocities......Voltaire.

    June 13, 2012 at 5:37 am | Reply
    • Rational Libertarian

      Voltaire: The man who spoke the greatest last words in the history of humanity.

      June 13, 2012 at 5:49 am | Reply
  15. Accius

    DEATH TO ISLAM

    June 13, 2012 at 4:45 am | Reply
    • Rational Libertarian

      Death to fundamentalism!

      June 13, 2012 at 5:08 am | Reply
    • TheMendicantBias

      You must be the guy's long-lost brother. You appear to have the same thought process and genes.

      Dumb***.

      June 13, 2012 at 5:12 am | Reply
  16. amirion

    Now Merah's father is suing the French government because they killed his terrorist son. Merah's father spent five years in prison because of druck trafficking. I wonder how he was able to educate his children to avoid being brainwashed by the AQ recruiters. If he was not able to raise properly his children, the French government should pursue legally him, according to French laws.

    June 13, 2012 at 4:19 am | Reply
    • Rational Libertarian

      His dad is clearly an idiot if he thinks he has a case against the French government, but to say that he can be held accountable for his son's actions is also ridiculous. Merah was a grown man when he committed these crimes. Unless his dad put a gun to his head and forced him to kill those people, he isn't accountable.

      June 13, 2012 at 5:20 am | Reply
      • Harry

        Sure, go ahead and support terrorism. You must be a Muslim.

        June 13, 2012 at 9:00 am |
  17. SAID

    WELL DONE MISSION. FRENCH WILL REGRET THEIR ACTIONS AGAINST ISLAMIC WAY OF WOMEN DRESSING.

    June 13, 2012 at 4:09 am | Reply
    • amirion

      If you are stating that a criminal terrorist attack is a "well done mission", this is apology for terrorism and this is a crime even under sharia laws. Your retarded point of view that because French authorities have banned the Muslim veil, France and its non-Muslim citizens should be punished by terroristm is also criminal. Nobody ever in history managed to stop for a long time the modernizing forces of society. Communism fell after only 70 years. Muslim terrorism is also failing, having lost much support in the last 10 years among the citizens of Muslim countries, as research show. Terror is a reaction to those modernizing forces that are cornering the last remnants of religious medieval obscurantists who think citizens should live like 1,300 years ago and impose women to walk behind men like inferior human beings.

      June 13, 2012 at 4:28 am | Reply
    • No Time For Idiots

      The only well done mission in this case was the French sniper that put a hole in this POS's head. PS. You're a POS also.

      June 13, 2012 at 9:45 am | Reply

Post a comment


 

CNN welcomes a lively and courteous discussion as long as you follow the Rules of Conduct set forth in our Terms of Service. Comments are not pre-screened before they post. You agree that anything you post may be used, along with your name and profile picture, in accordance with our Privacy Policy and the license you have granted pursuant to our Terms of Service.