Survey: Veterans say Afghanistan, Iraq wars not worth it
US Marines on patrol in Helmand Province, Afghanistan Photo From: AFP/Getty Images
October 5th, 2011
02:37 PM ET

Survey: Veterans say Afghanistan, Iraq wars not worth it

By CNN's Moni Basu

America's veterans are proud of their military service, but in a new report published Wednesday, they expressed ambivalence about the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq.

In a new Pew Research Center report on war and sacrifice, half of post-9/11 veterans said the Afghanistan war has been worth fighting. Only 44% felt that way about Iraq, and one-third said both wars were worth the costs.

Some of those costs were outlined in the Pew study, which comes out as the United States marks the 10th anniversary Friday of the Afghanistan conflict, the longest-running war in the nation's history.

For instance, four of every 10 veterans reported they had difficulties adjusting back to life at home after the combat zone, and 37% said they suffered from post-traumatic stress, even though they might not have been formally diagnosed as such.

"The ambivalence that many post-9/11 veterans feel about their military mission has a parallel in the mixture of benefits and burdens they report having experienced since their return to civilian life," the report said.

After the first U.S. troops headed to the mountains and valleys of the Hindu Kush in October 2001, the United States entered yet another war in Iraq.

The length of the conflicts has shaped attitudes toward war and sacrifice, the survey found.

"These wars, this time period has been unique in our history," said Paul Taylor, one of the authors of the study. "This has been the longest period of sustained conflict in our history and the fight has been carried by the smallest share."

Most Americans remain supportive of their all-volunteer military. (Only one-half of 1% of the population has been on active-duty service in the past decade.) Nine out of 10 expressed pride in the troops, and three-quarters say they thanked someone in the military.

But 45% - higher than among military respondents - said neither of the wars fought after the September 11, 2001, attacks has been worth the cost, and only a quarter said they were following news of the wars closely. Half said the wars have made little difference in their lives.

The disconnect between civilian and military worlds was apparent in other responses as well.

Veterans - 84% - said most Americans do not understand the myriad problems they and their families have had to face, including long separations, physical and psychological injuries, and stress. Some 71% of the public agreed.

"There is some registration that there is a gap in understanding, a gap in experience," Taylor said. "The veterans have borne the burdens of war but come back with emotional and psychological challenges to a country that does not understand them."

Most Americans - 83% - acknowledge military members and their families have had to make a lot of sacrifices. Some military personnel have deployed as many as four or five times to Iraq and Afghanistan.

But only 26% feel it's unfair that the burden has fallen to the military. In fact, 70% view it as "just part of being in the military."

Taylor said the longevity of the wars and the stress of multiple deployments played a role in shaping opinions - both military and civilian.

Pew surveyed 1,853 veterans, including 712 who served in the military after the 9/11 attacks. The general public survey was conducted among 2,003 adult respondents.

More than half of post-9/11 veterans also felt that too much reliance on military force to combat terrorism leads to more terrorism. On this topic, the public view was nearly identical: 52% said too much force is not a recipe for success.

Post-9/11 veterans were keen supporters of nation-building, with 59% supporting those roles for America's service members. But only 45% of the public and pre-9/11 veterans thought the military should be involved.

Drones drew big support in the survey. Nearly nine in 10 of all veterans approved the use of unmanned planes, such as the one used in last week's killing of al Qaeda's Anwar al-Awlaki in Yemen, and 68% of civilians agreed.

Not surprisingly, those who consider nation-building activities inappropriate are especially likely to believe the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq have not been worth fighting.

Very few Americans support a return of the draft - more than eight in 10 post-9/11 veterans and 74% of the public said no.

Despite doubts expressed about the wars, a majority of post-9/11 veterans said their service helped them mature and gain self-confidence.

The report, said Pew, presents "what we believe is a vivid portrait - albeit one painted exclusively in numbers - of the rewards and burdens of serving in the all-volunteer military during the past decade."

The margin of sampling error for results in the veterans survey is plus or minus 3.5 percentage points; for pre-9/11 veterans, 3.9 percentage points; and for those who served after 9/11, 5.7 percentage points. For the general public, the margin of error is plus or minus 2.5 percentage points.

Post by:
Filed under: 10 years of war • 9/11 • Afghanistan • Foreign Policy • Iraq • Military • Pentagon
soundoff (6 Responses)
  1. Sydnij Eugeniee

    Thanks a lot for giving everyone an exceptionally pleasant opportunity to discover important secrets from this blog. It really is so pleasing plus full of fun for me personally and my office co-workers to visit your site the equivalent of thrice per week to find out the new guidance you will have. And lastly, I am actually fulfilled with the impressive thoughts you give. Selected 3 areas on this page are indeed the most beneficial we have ever had.

    August 1, 2012 at 7:07 am | Reply
  2. Andrew

    I can't claim to speak for all veterans. I do hope my own experience can help explain why what appears to be ambivalence or mixed feelings really isn't either. Before diving into that, though, a little bit about me: I am a fifteen-year Army veteran, who served in the Balkans in the '90s and after a short break in service returned after 9/11. I have been to Afghanistan twice, once on the front lines, and once in a "nation building" role.

    Of the countless Soldiers with whom I've worked over the years, I've encountered just as many opinions about the rightness or wrongness of what we're doing in Iraq and Afghanistan. We are, after all, Americans. The wide range of opinions–for, against, or somewhere in between–is not surprising at all.

    This article alludes to pride in service, and in fact the Pew report cites that 96% of post-9/11 veterans are proud of their service. So how does that jibe with the split opinion about the larger issue of whether or not the wars have been worth the cost? I believe that the answer comes from the unique spirit of our veterans themselves.

    What makes our Soldiers–and airmen, sailors, and Marines–so special is that when it comes time to focus on the mission, the unit, and their buddies, everything else is put aside. They live and breathe the ideals of service and duty, and that shines through in their nearly-universal pride in having done their part.

    I think it actually makes sense that our veterans willingly bear the costs in spite of their personal beliefs about the benefits. The Soldiers I've known are the kind of men and women who volunteer to bear the burden that others won't, merely because somebody has to. I am proud of them, and more importantly, am proud to have served among them.

    October 13, 2011 at 10:55 pm | Reply
    • Kibeku

      Boy, i wish i had the best answer for you. I am going thorguh the same thing you are. My husband had to go back to school so that we could get some good insurance. Right now we are recieving State Medicaid and they are going us all kinds of trouble. They all tring to tell us that my husbands G.I. bill is income!!! Can you beleive it! Good luck finding something that works for your family. We all know how hard it is to find some decent medical insurance here in this country

      June 28, 2012 at 8:12 pm | Reply
  3. Migo

    and OPINION polls are only that....OPINIONS not necessarily facts.

    October 5, 2011 at 3:15 pm | Reply
    • Trisha

      I saw a bumper stieckr that read: stop this endless war but had the end part marked off and the word use written above it. I like the one that reads: 01-20-09 the end of an error.OOps I forget to add .net at the end of my e-mail address and now I have to type the whole thing over again, arrrrgh!

      June 28, 2012 at 3:22 pm | Reply
  4. Migo

    "The ambivalence that many post-9/11 veterans feel about their military mission has a parallel in the mixture of benefits and burdens they report having experienced since their return to civilian life," the report said.

    There are so many logical errors in the above statement:

    Straw Dog
    Fallacy of accident or sweeping generalization
    Irrelevant conclusion
    argumentum ad populum
    Affirming the consequent
    Denying the antecedent
    Fallacy of false cause
    post hoc ergo propter hoc:
    cum hoc ergo propter hoc:

    Only one of these actually applies....pick one.

    October 5, 2011 at 3:14 pm | Reply

Post a comment


 

CNN welcomes a lively and courteous discussion as long as you follow the Rules of Conduct set forth in our Terms of Service. Comments are not pre-screened before they post. You agree that anything you post may be used, along with your name and profile picture, in accordance with our Privacy Policy and the license you have granted pursuant to our Terms of Service.